Search bioRxiv⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Prieto, T.

Publications and source records attributed to Prieto, T..

9 recordsLinked to original sources

Large-scale single-cell phylogenetic mapping of clonal evolution in the human aging esophagus

The human somatic genome evolves throughout our lifespan, producing mosaic individuals comprising clones harboring different mutations across tissues. While clonal expansions in the hematopoietic system have been extensively characterized and reported to be nearly ubiquitous, clonal mosaicism (CM) has more recently also been described across multiple solid tissues. However, outstanding questions remain about the parameters and processes of human somatic evolution in non-cancerous solid human tissues, including when clones arise, how they evolve over time, and what mechanisms lead to their expansion. Questions of timing and clonal dynamics can be addressed through phylogenetic reconstruction, which serves as a temporal microscope, while uncovering the mechanisms of expansion necessitates simultaneous phenotypic profiling. To address this gap, here we develop Single-cell Miniaturized Automated Reverse Transcription and Primary Template-directed Amplification (SMART-PTA) for joint single-cell whole-genome and whole-transcriptome sequencing for large scale and cost efficient interrogation of solid tissue CM. We established a workflow that generates hundreds of matched single-cell whole genome and transcriptome libraries within a week. We profiled phenotypically normal esophagus tissue from four aged donors and used somatic variants to build high-resolution single-cell lineages from >2,700 cells with accompanying transcriptomic information, reconstructing >70 years of somatic evolution. T cell expansions identified from T cell receptor (TCR) sequences validated the clonal structure of the single-nucleotide variant (SNV)-based phylogenies and phylogenetic cross-correlation analysis showed that epithelial cells had higher degrees of shared ancestry by spatial location compared to immune cells. Mapping mutation signatures to the phylogenetic tree revealed the emergence of tobacco/alcohol exposure-related signatures later in life, consistent with the donors exposure histories. We identified variants in driver genes that were previously reported in the phenotypically normal esophagus, detecting clonal expansions harboring mutations in genes including TP53 and FAT1. We mapped the evolution of clones with both monoallelic as well as biallelic TP53 loss, including a clone associated with high expression of cell cycling genes and higher chromosome instability. Leveraging the matched transcriptome data, we uncovered cell type biases in mutant clones, with a higher proportion of TP53 or FAT1-mutant cells in an earlier basal epithelial cell state compared to wild-type cells. We further observed copy-neutral loss of heterozygosity (CNLOH) events on chromosome 9q that spanned the NOTCH1 locus in up to [~]35% of epithelial cells. Mapping CNLOH events to the phylogenetic tree revealed a striking pattern in which CNLOH was separately acquired many times, reflecting convergent evolution. Cells with CNLOH events were biased towards the earlier basal epithelial state, suggestive of a selective advantage that leads to prevalent recurrence of chr9q CNLOH. Together, we demonstrate that SMART-PTA is an efficient, scalable approach for single-cell whole-genome and whole-transcriptome profiling to build phenotypically annotated single-cell phylogenies with enough throughput and power for application to normal tissue somatic evolution. Moreover, we reconstruct the evolutionary history of the esophageal epithelium at high scale and resolution, providing a window into the dynamics and processes that shape clonal expansions in phenotypically normal tissues throughout a lifespan.

genomics↗

Paired plus-minus sequencing is an ultra-high throughput and accurate method for dual strand sequencing of DNA molecules

Distinguishing real biological variation in the form of single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) from errors is a major challenge for genome sequencing technologies. This is particularly true in settings where SNVs are at low frequency such as cancer detection through liquid biopsy, or human somatic mosaicism. State-of-the-art molecular denoising approaches for DNA sequencing rely on duplex sequencing, where both strands of a single DNA molecule are sequenced to discern true variants from errors arising from single stranded DNA damage. However, such duplex approaches typically require massive over-sequencing to overcome low capture rates of duplex molecules. To address these challenges, we introduce paired plus-minus sequencing (ppmSeq) technology, in which both DNA strands are partitioned and clonally amplified on sequencing beads through emulsion PCR. In this reaction, both strands of a double-stranded DNA molecule contribute to a single sequencing read, allowing for a duplex yield that scales linearly with sequencing coverage across a wide range of inputs (1.8-98 ng). We benchmarked ppmSeq against current duplex sequencing technologies, demonstrating superior duplex recovery with ppmSeq, with a rate of 44%{+/-}5.5% (compared to [~]5-11% for leading duplex technologies). Using both genomic as well as cell-free DNA, we established error rates for ppmSeq, which had residual SNV detection error rates as low as 7.98x10-8 for gDNA (using an end-repair protocol with dideoxy nucleotides) and 3.5x10-7{+/-}7.5x10-8 for cell-free DNA. To test the capabilities of ppmSeq for error-corrected whole-genome sequencing (WGS) for clinical application, we assessed circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) detection for disease monitoring in cancer patients. We demonstrated that ppmSeq enables powerful tumor-informed ctDNA detection at concentrations of 10-4 across most cancers, parts per million sensitivity in cancers with high mutation burden, and further increased sensitivity with higher sequencing depth. We then leveraged genome-wide trinucleotide mutation patterns characteristic of urothelial (APOBEC3-related and platinum exposure-related signatures) and lung (tobacco-exposure-related signatures) cancers to perform tumor-naive ctDNA detection, showing that ppmSeq can identify a disease-specific signal in plasma cell-free DNA without a matched tumor, and that this signal correlates with imaging-based disease metrics. Altogether, ppmSeq provides an error-corrected, cost-efficient and scalable approach for high-fidelity WGS that can be harnessed for challenging clinical applications and emerging frontiers in human somatic genetics where high accuracy is required for mutation identification.

genomics↗

Measuring Longitudinal Genome-wide Clonal Evolution of Pediatric Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia at Single-Cell Resolution

Approximately 15-20% of children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (pALL) are not cured despite years of treatment with more than ten chemotherapeutic agents, yet bulk sequencing reveals minimal somatic variation that could explain genetic treatment resistance. Using error-corrected bulk sequencing, and primary template-directed amplification (PTA)-enabled single-cell exome and whole-genome sequencing, we discovered much more genetic diversity in pALL. Individual leukemic cells harbor 3.7-fold more mutations (mean 3,553) than detected in bulk samples (mean 965). Many ETV6-RUNX1 patients harbor multiple independent ras-mutated clones, and we also identified convergent evolution of JAK2 mutations as well as copy number alterations. PTA-based phylogenetic analysis of over 150 single-cell genomes linked heritable phenotypes to specific genetic alterations and identified low-frequency clones harboring mutations in treatment resistance-associated genes (ITGA9, NTRK3, SULF2) that increased in frequency during treatment. These findings reveal extensive hidden genetic diversity in pALL while providing a framework for the early detection of high-risk leukemic populations.

cancer biology↗

Defining ancestry, heritability and plasticity of cellular phenotypes in somatic evolution

The broad application of single-cell RNA sequencing has revealed transcriptional cell state heterogeneity across diverse healthy and malignant somatic tissues. Recent advances in lineage tracing technologies have further enabled the simultaneous capture of cell transcriptional state along with cellular ancestry thus enabling the study of somatic evolution at an unprecedented resolution; however, new analytical approaches are needed to fully harness these data. Here we introduce PATH (Phylogenetic Analysis of Transcriptional Heritability), an analytical framework, which draws upon classic approaches in species evolution, to quantify heritability and plasticity of somatic phenotypes, including transcriptional states. The PATH framework further allows for the inference of cell state transition dynamics by linking a model of cellular evolutionary dynamics with our measure of heritability versus plasticity. We evaluate the robustness of this approach by testing a range of biological and technical features in simulations of somatic evolution. We then apply PATH to characterize previously published and newly generated single-cell phylogenies, reconstructed from either native or artificial lineage markers, with matching cellular state profiling. PATH recovered developmental relationships in mouse embryogenesis, and revealed how anatomic proximity influences neural relatedness in the developing zebrafish brain. In cancer, PATH dissected the heritability of the epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition in a mouse model of pancreatic cancer, and the heritability versus plasticity of transcriptionally-defined cell states in human glioblastoma. Finally, PATH revealed phenotypic heritability patterns in a phylogeny reconstructed from single-cell whole genome sequencing of a B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia patient sample. Altogether, by bringing together perspectives from evolutionary biology and emerging single-cell technologies, PATH formally connects the analysis of cell state diversity and somatic evolution, providing quantification of critical aspects of these processes and replacing qualitative conceptions of "plasticity" with quantitative measures of cell state transitions and heritability.

evolutionary biology↗

The evolution of two transmissible leukaemias colonizing the coasts of Europe

Transmissible cancers are malignant cell clones that spread among individuals through transfer of living cancer cells. Several such cancers, collectively known as bivalve transmissible neoplasia (BTN), are known to infect and cause leukaemia in marine bivalve molluscs. This is the case of BTN clones affecting the common cockle, Cerastoderma edule, which inhabits the Atlantic coasts of Europe and north-west Africa. To investigate the origin and evolution of contagious cancers in common cockles, we collected 6,854 C. edule specimens and diagnosed 390 cases of BTN. We then generated a reference genome for the species and assessed genomic variation in the genomes of 61 BTN tumours. Analysis of tumour-specific variants confirmed the existence of two cockle BTN lineages with independent clonal origins, and gene expression patterns supported their status as haemocyte-derived marine leukaemias. Examination of mitochondrial DNA sequences revealed several mitochondrial capture events in BTN, as well as co-infection of cockles by different tumour lineages. Mutational analyses identified two lineage-specific mutational signatures, one of which resembles a signature associated with DNA alkylation. Karyotypic and copy number analyses uncovered genomes marked by pervasive instability and polyploidy. Whole-genome duplication, amplification of oncogenes CCND3 and MDM2, and deletion of the DNA alkylation repair gene MGMT, are likely drivers of BTN evolution. Characterization of satellite DNA identified elements with vast expansions in the cockle germ line, yet absent from BTN tumours, suggesting ancient clonal origins. Our study illuminates the evolution of contagious cancers under the sea, and reveals long-term tolerance of extreme instability in neoplastic genomes.

evolutionary biology↗

Integrated Single-Cell Genotyping and Chromatin Accessibility Charts JAK2V617F Human Hematopoietic Differentiation

In normal somatic tissue differentiation, changes in chromatin accessibility govern priming and commitment of precursors towards cellular fates. In turn, somatic mutations can disrupt differentiation topologies leading to abnormal clonal outgrowth. However, defining the impact of somatic mutations on the epigenome in human samples is challenging due to admixed mutated and wildtype cells. To chart how somatic mutations disrupt epigenetic landscapes in human clonal outgrowths, we developed Genotyping of Targeted loci with single-cell Chromatin Accessibility (GoT-ChA). This high-throughput, broadly accessible platform links genotypes to chromatin accessibility at single-cell resolution, across thousands of cells within a single assay. We applied GoT-ChA to CD34+ cells from myeloproliferative neoplasm (MPN) patients with JAK2V617F-mutated hematopoiesis, where the JAK2 mutation is known to perturb hematopoietic differentiation. Differential accessibility analysis between wildtype and JAK2V617F mutant progenitors revealed both cell-intrinsic and cell state-specific shifts within mutant hematopoietic precursors. An early subset of mutant hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs) exhibited a cell-intrinsic pro-inflammatory signature characterized by increased NF-{kappa}B and JUN/FOS transcription factor motif accessibility. In addition, mutant HSPCs showed increased myeloid/erythroid epigenetic priming, preceding increased erythroid and megakaryocytic cellular output. Erythroid progenitors displayed aberrant regulation of the {gamma}-globin locus, providing an intrinsic epigenetic basis for the dysregulated fetal hemoglobin expression observed in MPNs. In contrast, megakaryocytic progenitors exhibited a more specialized inflammatory chromatin landscape relative to early HSPCs, with increased accessibility of pro-fibrotic JUN/FOS transcription factors. Notably, analysis of myelofibrosis patients treated with JAK inhibitors revealed an overall loss of mutant-specific phenotypes without modifying clonal burden, consistent with clinical responses. Finally, expansion of the multi-modality capability of GoT-ChA to integrate mitochondrial genome profiling and cell surface protein expression measurement enabled genotyping imputation and discovery of aberrant cellular phenotypes. Collectively, we show that the JAK2V617F mutation leads to epigenetic rewiring in a cell-intrinsic and cell type-specific manner. We envision that GoT-ChA will thus serve as a foundation for broad future explorations to uncover the critical link between mutated somatic genotypes and epigenetic alterations across clonal populations in malignant and non-malignant contexts.

cancer biology↗

Accuracy of somatic variant detection in multiregional tumor sequencing data

Multiregional bulk sequencing data is necessary to characterize intratumor genetic heterogeneity. Novel somatic variant calling approaches aim to address the particular characteristics of multiregional data, but it remains unclear to which extent they improve compared to single-sample strategies. Here we compared the performance of 16 single-nucleotide variant calling approaches on multiregional sequencing data under different scenarios with in-silico and real sequencing reads, including varying sequencing coverage and increasing levels of spatial clonal admixture. Under the conditions simulated, methods that use information across multiple samples do not necessarily perform better than some of the standard calling methods that work sample by sample. Nonetheless, our results indicate that under difficult conditions, Mutect2 in multisample mode, in combination with a correction step, seems to perform best. Our analysis provides data-driven guidance for users and developers of somatic variant calling tools.

bioinformatics↗

Comparison of single-cell whole-genome amplification strategies

Single-cell genomics is an alluring area that holds the potential to change the way we understand cell populations. Due to the small amount of DNA within a single cell, whole-genome amplification becomes a mandatory step in many single-cell applications. Unfortunately, single-cell whole-genome amplification (scWGA) strategies suffer from several technical biases that complicate the posterior interpretation of the data. Here we compared the performance of six different scWGA methods (GenomiPhi, REPLIg, TruePrime, Ampli1, MALBAC, and PicoPLEX) after amplifying and low-pass sequencing the complete genome of 230 healthy/tumoral human cells. Overall, REPLIg outperformed competing methods regarding DNA yield, amplicon size, amplification breadth, amplification uniformity -being the only method with a random amplification bias-, and false single-nucleotide variant calls. On the other hand, non-MDA methods, and in particular Ampli1, showed less allelic imbalance and ADO, more reliable copy-number profiles and less chimeric amplicons. While no single scWGA method showed optimal performance for every aspect, they clearly have distinct advantages. Our results provide a convenient guide for selecting a scWGA method depending on the question of interest while revealing relevant weaknesses that should be considered during the analysis and interpretation of single-cell sequencing data.

genomics↗

Biased evolutionary inferences from bulk tumor samples

It is generally agreed that tumors are composed of multiple cell clones defined by different somatic mutations. Characterizing the evolutionary mechanisms driving this intratumor genetic heterogeneity (ITH) is crucial to improve both cancer diagnosis and therapeutic strategies. For that purpose, recent ITH studies have focused on qualitative comparisons of mutational profiles derived from bulk sequencing of multiple tumor samples extracted from the same patient. Here, we show some examples where the naive use of bulk data in multiregional studies may lead to erroneous inferences of the evolutionary trajectories that underlie tumor progression, including biased timing of somatic mutations, spurious parallel mutation events, and/or incorrect chronological ordering of metastatic events. In addition, we analyze three real datasets to highlight how the use of bulk mutational profiles instead of inferred clones can lead to different conclusions about mutational recurrence and population structure.

evolutionary biology↗