Biology subjects

O'Malley, R. C.

Publications and source records attributed to O'Malley, R. C..

16 recordsLinked to original sources

bioRxiv2026

Positional grammar of transcription factor binding partitions developmental and stress-response regulation in plants

Understanding how transcription factor binding site (TFBS) position influences gene regulation remains a fundamental challenge in plants. Here, we integrate conserved multiDAP TFBS maps for 244 transcription factors (TFs) with single-nucleus chromatin accessibility, cell type-resolved gene expression, and hormone-response datasets across Brassicaceae species to determine how TFBS position relates to regulatory function. Although conserved TFBSs are enriched near transcription start sites (TSSs), TSS-proximal accessibility poorly predicts cell type-specific expression. Instead, cell type-specific expression correlates best with conserved TFBSs embedded in cell type-restricted chromatin, with TF family-specific distributions across distal promoters and introns. In contrast, TSS-proximal TFBSs in broadly accessible chromatin are associated with rapid transcriptional responses to abiotic and biotic stress hormones. Coding sequence TFBSs mark a distinct regulatory context in which the same DNA sequence encodes both amino acid sequence and TF motifs, including evidence that CDS-localized ABR1 binding may contribute to repression during hormone response. Finally, distal upstream regions contain conserved multi-family TF clusters with enhancer-like features overlapping rare cell type-specific accessible chromatin and enriched near genes controlling embryonic, meristematic, and hormone-dependent developmental patterning. Together, these results support a positional grammar in which TFBS position and chromatin context jointly partition developmental, stress-responsive, and repressive regulatory output in plants.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2025

TOR inhibition drives accumulation of amino acids through transcriptional activation in algae

Cellular homeostasis is maintained by the balance between energy production and breakdown and is fundamental to all forms of life. The conserved, ancient target of rapamycin (TOR) kinase is a central metabolic regulator in eukaryotes that integrates carbon and nitrogen to maintain homeostasis and promote growth and development through protein synthesis. While TOR regulatory mechanisms of amino acid accumulation are well known in yeast and mammals, they remain unknown in photosynthetic organisms. Here, we developed the unicellular green alga Chromochloris zofingiensis as a simpler model system for understanding TOR function. Multiomics experiments showed that TOR inhibition leads to an increase in amino acid levels independent of hexokinase-mediated glucose signaling. We observed upregulation of selective amino acid biosynthesis pathways at the transcript and protein levels as potential mechanisms driving the increase in amino acids. Transcriptomics and proteomics experiments identified a basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) transcription factor with rapid upregulation during TOR inhibition. DAP-seq analysis demonstrated that bHLH can bind directly to the promoters of amino acid biosynthesis genes, potentially regulating their transcription in response to TOR inhibition. We found high conservation of the bHLH-binding motif in the genomes of other green algae and plants, suggesting a conserved regulatory mechanism for amino acid biosynthesis across Viridiplantae. Phosphoproteomics experiments also revealed novel conserved targets that are not currently recognized as part of the TOR pathway. Altogether, our findings elucidate the transcriptional regulation of amino acid metabolism and explain how TOR regulates nitrogen metabolism to support growth and development in photosynthetic organisms. Significance StatementCarbon and nitrogen metabolism play key roles in enhancing plant yield and reducing fertilizer use. Thus, improving nitrogen utilization can significantly boost crop productivity and algal biotechnology. From yeast to plants to mammals, the protein target of rapamycin (TOR) kinase is an essential metabolic regulator. Here, we developed the unicellular green alga Chromochloris zofingiensis as a simpler system to study conserved mechanisms in TOR signaling. Using a multiomics approach, we showed transcriptional regulation of amino acid accumulation upon TOR inhibition and identified a transcription factor with evolutionarily conserved DNA binding sites in nitrogen metabolism genes. We also discovered novel conserved targets of TOR. Our study demonstrates the role of TOR in regulating nitrogen metabolism to support growth and development in photosynthetic organisms.

plant biology↗

bioRxiv2025

Single-cell-level response to drought in Sorghum bicolor reveals novel targets for improving water use efficiency

Increasing drought threatens global agriculture, especially in water-limited regions. Sorghum bicolor, a drought-tolerant C4 grass, is a promising bioenergy crop for cultivation on marginal lands, yet its molecular drought responses remain poorly understood. To uncover single-cell-level transcriptional responses to drought, we performed single-nucleus RNA sequencing on mature sorghum leaves under well-watered and drought conditions. We identified major cell types and analyzed differential gene expression across mesophyll, bundle sheath, epidermal, vascular, and stomatal cells. Surprisingly, drought effects on transcriptomes exceeded differences due to cell identity, revealing a shared response across cell types. We leveraged this convergence to identify candidate regulators of drought-responsive gene expression. These findings advance our understanding of sorghum drought adaptation and offer new targets for engineering enhanced water use efficiency in bioenergy crops.

plant biology↗

bioRxiv2025

A novel regulator of the fungal phosphate starvation response revealed by transcriptional profiling and DNA affinity purification sequencing

Cells must accurately sense and respond to nutrients to compete for resources and establish growth. Phosphate is a critical nutrient source necessary for signaling, energy metabolism, and synthesis of nucleic acids, phospholipids, and cellular metabolites. During phosphate limitation, fungi import phosphate from the environment and liberate phosphate from phosphate-containing molecules in the cell. In the model filamentous fungus Neurospora crassa, the phosphate starvation response is regulated by the conserved transcription factor NUC-1. The activity of NUC-1 is repressed by a complex of the cyclin-dependent kinase MDK-1 and the cyclin PREG when phosphate is plentiful. When phosphate is limiting, NUC-1 repression by MDK-1/PREG is relieved by the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor NUC-2. We investigated the global response of N. crassa to phosphate starvation. During phosphate starvation, NUC-1 directly activated expression of genes encoding phosphatases, nucleases, and a phosphate transporter and directly repressed genes associated with the ribosome. Additionally, NUC-1 indirectly activated the expression of an uncharacterized transcription factor, which we named nuc-3. NUC-3 directly repressed the expression of genes involved in phosphate acquisition and liberation after an extended period of phosphate starvation. Additionally, NUC-3 directly repressed expression of the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor nuc-2. Thus, through the combination of NUC-3 direct repression of genes in the phosphate starvation response and nuc-2, an activator of the phosphate starvation response, NUC-3 serves to act as a brake on the phosphate starvation response after an extended period of phosphate starvation. This braking mechanism could reduce transcription, a phosphate-intensive process, in conditions when phosphate is limiting. IMPORTANCEFungi evolved regulatory networks to respond to available nutrients. Phosphate is frequently a limiting nutrient for fungi critical for many cellular functions, including nucleic acid and phospholipid biosynthesis, cell signaling, and energy metabolism. The fungal response to phosphate limitation is important in interactions with plants and animals. We investigated the global transcriptional response to phosphate starvation and the role of a major transcriptional regulator, NUC-1, in the model filamentous fungus Neurospora crassa. Our data shows NUC-1 is a bifunctional transcription factor that directly activates phosphate acquisition genes, while directly repressing genes associated with phosphate-intensive processes. NUC-1 indirectly regulates an uncharacterized transcription factor, which we named nuc-3. NUC-3 directly represses phosphate acquisition genes and nuc-2, an activator of the phosphate starvation response, during extended periods of phosphate starvation. Thus, NUC-3 acts as a brake on the phosphate starvation response to reduce phosphate-intensive activities, like transcriptional activation, when phosphate starvation persists.

genetics↗

bioRxiv2025

Genome-wide exploration of the transcriptional regulatory landscape in the early-diverging fungus R. microsporus reveals pervasive DNA methyl adenine regulatory network

Genetic regulation mechanisms rely on complex transcriptional networks that are often difficult to decipher. The study of transcription factor (TF) binding sites and their targets has traditionally faced scalability challenges, hindering comprehensive cistrome analyses. However, the development of the DNA affinity purification and sequencing (DAP-seq) technique has allowed unprecedented large-scale studies at genome-wide level of TF binding with high reproducibility. In this study, we apply this technique to the human opportunistic pathogen R. microsporus, a mucoralean fungus belonging to the understudied group of early-diverging fungi (EDF). We characterize genome-wide binding sites of 58 TFs encoded by genes regulated through adenine methylation and representing major TF families, representing the most extensive DAP-seq study in filamentous fungi. This analysis reveals their binding profiles and recognized sequences, expanding and diversifying the catalog of known fungal motifs. By integrating this data with DNA 6-methyladenine profiling, we uncover the extensive direct and indirect impact of this epigenetic modification on the regulation of gene expression. Furthermore, the generated data facilitates the identification and functional characterization of TFs involved in biologically relevant processes, such as zinc metabolism and light response, serving as a proof of concept for the utility of the DAP-seq data. These findings not only enhance our understanding of regulatory mechanisms in R. microsporus but also provide broader insights into gene regulation across the fungal kingdom.

genetics↗

bioRxiv2024

An atlas of conserved transcription factor binding sites reveals the cell type-resolved gene regulatory landscape of flowering plants

Transcription factors (TFs) are proteins that bind DNA to control where and when genes are expressed. In plants, dozens of TF families interact with distinct sets of binding sites (TFBSs) that reflect each TFs role in organismal function and species-specific adaptations. However, defining these roles and understanding broader patterns of regulatory evolution remains challenging, as predicted TFBSs may lack a clear impact on transcription, and experimentally-derived TF binding maps to date are modest in scale or restricted to model organisms. Here, we present a scalable TFBS assay that we leveraged to create an atlas of nearly 3,000 genome-wide binding site maps for 360 TFs in 10 species spanning 150 million years of flowering plant evolution. We find that TF orthologs from distant species retain nearly identical binding preferences, suggesting that regulatory evolution primarily arises from gain and loss of TFBSs. Within lineages however, conserved TFBSs are over-represented and found in regions harboring signatures of functional regulatory elements. Moreover, genes with conserved TFBSs showed a striking enrichment for cell type-specific expression in single-nuclei RNA atlases, providing a robust marker of each TFs activity and developmental role. Finally, we compare distant lineages, illustrating how ancient regulatory modules were recruited and rewired to enable adaptations underlying the evolutionary success of grasses.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2024

Shoring up the base: the development and regulation of cortical sclerenchyma in grass nodal roots

Plants depend on the combined action of a shoot-root-soil system to maintain their anchorage to the soil. Mechanical failure of any component of this system results in lodging, a permanent and irreversible inability to maintain vertical orientation. Models of anchorage in grass crops identify the compressive strength of roots near the soil surface as key determinant of resistance to lodging. Indeed, studies of disparate grasses report a ring of thickened, sclerenchyma cells surrounding the root cortex, present only at the base of nodal roots. Here, in the investigation of the development and regulation of this agronomically important trait, we show that development of these cells is uncoupled from the maturation of other secondary cell wall-fortified cells, and that cortical sclerenchyma wall thickening is stimulated by mechanical forces transduced from the shoot to the root. We also show that exogenous application of gibberellic acid stimulates thickening of lignified cell types in the root, including cortical sclerenchyma, but is not sufficient to establish sclerenchyma identity in cortex cells. Leveraging the ability to manipulate cortex development via mechanical stimulus, we show that cortical sclerenchyma development alters root mechanical properties and improves resistance to lodging. We describe transcriptome changes associated with cortical sclerenchyma development under both ambient and mechanically stimulated conditions and identify SECONDARY WALL NAC7 as a putative regulator of mechanically responsive cortex cell wall development at the root base.

plant biology↗

bioRxiv2023

Spatial Co-transcriptomics Reveals Discrete Stages of the Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Symbiosis

The symbiotic interaction of plants with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AM fungi) is ancient and widespread. Plants provide AM fungi with carbon in exchange for nutrients and water, making this interaction a prime target for crop improvement. However, plant-fungal interactions are restricted to a small subset of root cells, precluding the application of most conventional functional genomic techniques to study the molecular bases of these interactions. Here we used single-nucleus and spatial RNA sequencing to explore both M. truncatula and R. irregularis transcriptomes in AM symbiosis at cellular and spatial resolution. Integrated spatially-registered single-cell maps of interacting cells revealed major infected and uninfected plant root cell types. We observed that cortex cells exhibit distinct transcriptome profiles during different stages of colonization by AM fungi, indicating dynamic interplay between both organisms during establishment of the cellular interface enabling successful symbiosis. Our study provides insight into a symbiotic relationship of major agricultural and environmental importance and demonstrates a paradigm combining single-cell and spatial transcriptomics for the analysis of complex organismal interactions.

plant biology↗

bioRxiv2022

High-throughput Identification of Novel Heat Tolerance Genes via Genome-wide Pooled Mutant Screens in the Model Green Alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Different high temperatures adversely affect crop and algal yields with various responses in photosynthetic cells. The list of genes required for thermotolerance remains elusive. Additionally, it is unclear how carbon source availability affects heat responses in plants and algae. We utilized the insertional, indexed, genome-saturating mutant library of the unicellular, eukaryotic green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii to perform genome-wide, quantitative, pooled screens under moderate (35{degrees}C) or acute (40{degrees}C) high temperatures with or without organic carbon sources. We identified heat-sensitive mutants based on quantitative growth rates and identified putative heat tolerance genes (HTGs). By triangulating HTGs with heat-induced transcripts or proteins in wildtype cultures and MapMan functional annotations, we present a high/medium-confidence list of 933 Chlamydomonas genes with putative roles in heat tolerance. Triangulated HTGs include those with known thermotolerance roles and novel genes with little or no functional annotation. About 50% of these high-confidence HTGs in Chlamydomonas have orthologs in green lineage organisms, including crop species. Arabidopsis thaliana mutants deficient in the ortholog of a high-confidence Chlamydomonas HTG were also heat sensitive. This work expands our knowledge of heat responses in photosynthetic cells and provides engineering targets to improve thermotolerance in algae and crops.

plant biology↗

bioRxiv2022

Transcriptome and DNA methylome dynamics reveal differential characteristics of inflorescence development between two ecotypes in Panicum hallii

The morphological diversity of the inflorescence determines flower and seed production, which is critical for plant adaptation and fitness. Cytosine methylation is an epigenetic mark that contributes to gene expression regulation during inflorescence development. Panicum hallii is a wild perennial grass in the subfamily Panicoideae that has been developed as a model to study perennial grass biology and adaptive evolution. Highly divergent inflorescences have evolved between the two major ecotypes in P. hallii, the upland ecotype with compact inflorescence and large seed and the lowland ecotype with an open inflorescence and small seed. Here we performed a comparative transcriptome and DNA methylome analysis across different stages of inflorescence between these two divergent ecotypes of P. hallii. Global transcriptome analysis identified differentially expressed genes (DEGs) involved in panicle divergence, stage-specific expression, and co-expression modules underlying inflorescence development. Comparing DNA methylome profiles revealed a remarkable level of differential DNA methylation associated with the evolution of the P. hallii inflorescence. We found that most differentially methylated regions (DMRs) occurred within the flanking regulatory regions of genes, especially the promoter. Integrative analysis of DEGs and DMRs characterized the global features of DMR-associated DEGs in the divergence of P. hallii inflorescence, which includes homologs of important inflorescence and seed developmental genes that have been previously identified in domesticated crops. Evolutionary analysis measured by Ka/Ks ratio suggested that most DMR-associated DEGs are under relatively strong purifying selection. This study provides insights into the transcriptome and epigenetic landscape of inflorescence divergence in P. hallii and a novel genomic resource for perennial grass biology. One sentence summaryA comparative transcriptome and DNA methylome analysis of inflorescence between upland and lowland ecotypes reveal gene expression and DNA methylation variation underlying inflorescence divergence in Panicum hallii.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2021

An optimized ChIP-Seq framework for profiling of histone modifications in Chromochloris zofingiensis

The eukaryotic green alga Chromochloris zofingiensis is a reference organism for studying carbon partitioning and a promising candidate for the production of biofuel precursors. Recent transcriptome profiling transformed our understanding of its biology and generally algal biology, but epigenetic regulation remains understudied and represents a fundamental gap in our understanding of algal gene expression. Chromatin Immunoprecipitation followed by deep sequencing (ChIP-Seq) is a powerful tool for the discovery of such mechanisms, by identifying genome-wide histone modification patterns and transcription factor-binding sites alike. Here, we established a ChIP-Seq framework for Chr. zofingiensis yielding over 20 million high quality reads per sample. The most critical steps in a ChIP experiment were optimized, including DNA shearing to obtain an average DNA fragment size of 250 bp and assessment of the recommended formaldehyde concentration for optimal DNA-protein crosslinking. We used this ChIP-Seq framework to generate a genome-wide map of the H3K4me3 distribution pattern and to integrate these data with matching RNA-Seq data. In line with observations from other organisms, H3K4me3 marks predominantly transcription start sites of genes. Our H3K4me3 ChIP-Seq data will pave the way for improved genome structural annotation in the emerging reference alga Chr. zofingiensis.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2021

Genome wide profiling of histone H3 lysine 4 methylation during the Chlamydomonas cell cycle reveals stable and dynamic properties of lysine 4 trimethylation at gene promoters and near ubiquitous lysine 4 monomethylation

Chromatin modifications are key epigenetic regulatory features with roles in various cellular events, yet histone mark identification, gene wide distribution and relationship to gene expression remains understudied in green algae. Histone lysine methylation is regarded as an active chromatin mark in many organisms, and is implicated in mediating active euchromatin. We interrogated the genome wide distribution pattern of mono- and trimethylated H3K4 using Chromatin-Immunoprecipitation followed by deep-sequencing (ChIP-Seq) during key phases of the Chlamydomonas cell cycle: early G1 phase (ZT1) when cells initiate biomass accumulation, S/M phase (ZT13) when cells are undergoing DNA replication and mitosis, and late G0 phase (ZT23) when they are quiescent. Tri-methylated H3K4 was predominantly enriched at TSSs of the majority of protein coding genes (85%). The likelihood of a gene being marked by H3K4me3 correlated with it being transcribed at one or more time points during the cell cycle but not necessarily by continuous active transcription. This finding even applied to early zygotic genes whose expression may be dormant for hundreds or thousands of generations between sexual cycles; but core meiotic genes were completely missing H3K4me3 peaks at their TSS. In addition, bi-directional promoters regulating expression of replication dependent histone genes, had transient H3K4me3 peaks that were present only during S/M phase when their expression peaked. In agreement with biochemical studies, mono-methylated H3K4 was the default state for the vast majority of histones that were outside of TSS and terminator regions of genes. A small fraction of the genome which was depleted of any H3 lysine methylation was enriched for DNA cytosine methylation and the genes within these DNA methylation islands were poorly expressed. Genome wide H3K4me3 ChIP-Seq data will be a valuable resource, facilitating gene structural annotation, as exemplified by our validation of hundreds of long non-coding RNA genes.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2021

The genome of stress tolerant crop wild relativePaspalum vaginatum leads to increased biomassproductivity in the crop Zea mays

A number of crop wild relatives can tolerate extreme stressed to a degree outside the range observed in their domesticated relatives. However, it is unclear whether or how the molecular mechanisms employed by these species can be translated to domesticated crops. Paspalum Paspalum vaginatum is a self-incompatible and multiply stress-tolerant wild relative of maize and sorghum. Here we describe the sequencing and pseudomolecule level assembly of a vegetatively propagated accession of P. vaginatum. Phylogenetic analysis based on 6,151 single-copy syntenic orthologous conserved in 6 related grass species placed paspalum as an outgroup of the maize-sorghum clade demonstrating paspalum as their closest sequenced wild relative. In parallel metabolic experiments, paspalum, but neither maize nor sorghum, exhibited significant increases in trehalose when grown under nutrient-deficit conditions. Inducing trehalose accumulation in maize, imitating the metabolic phenotype of paspalum, resulting in autophagy dependent increases in biomass accumulation.

plant biology↗

bioRxiv2021

Long-read metagenomics of soil communities reveals phylum-specific secondary metabolite dynamics

Microbial biosynthetic gene clusters (BGCs) encoding secondary metabolites are thought to impact a plethora of biologically mediated environmental processes, yet their discovery and functional characterization in natural microbiomes remains challenging. Here we describe deep long-read sequencing and assembly of metagenomes from biological soil crusts, a group of soil communities that are rich in BGCs. Taking advantage of the unusually long assemblies produced by this approach, we recovered nearly 3,000 BGCs for analysis, including 695 novel, full-length BGCs. Functional exploration through metatranscriptome analysis of a 3-day wetting experiment uncovered phylum-specific BGC expression upon activation from dormancy, elucidating distinct roles and complex phylogenetic and temporal dynamics in wetting processes. For example, a pronounced increase in BGC transcription occurs at night in cyanobacteria but not in other phyla, implicating BGCs in nutrient scavenging roles and niche competition. Taken together, our results demonstrate that long-read metagenomic sequencing combined with metatranscriptomic analysis provides a direct view into the functional dynamics of BGCs in environmental processes and suggests a central role of secondary metabolites in maintaining phylogenetically conserved niches within biocrusts.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2018

A network of MAP-Kinase pathways and transcription factors regulates cell-to-cell communication and cell wall integrity in Neurospora crassa

Maintenance of cell integrity and cell-to-cell communication are fundamental biological processes. Filamentous fungi, such as Neurospora crassa, depend on communication to locate compatible cells, coordinate cell fusion, and establish a robust hyphal network. Two MAP-Kinase pathways are essential for communication and cell fusion in N. crassa; the Cell Wall Integrity/MAK-1 pathway and the MAK-2 (signal response) pathway. Previous studies have demonstrated several points of cross talk between the MAK-1 and MAK-2 pathways, which is likely necessary for oordinating chemotropic growth toward an extracellular signal, and then mediating cell fusion. Canonical MAP-Kinase pathways begin with signal reception and end with a transcriptional response. Two transcription factors, ADV-1 and PP-1, are essential for communication and cell fusion. PP-1 is the conserved target of MAK-2, while it is unclear what targets ADV-1. We did RNAseq on{Delta} adv-1, {Delta}pp-1, and wild-type cells and found that ADV-1 and PP-1 have a shared regulon including many genes required for communication, cell fusion, growth, development, and stress response. We identified ADV-1 and PP-1 binding sites across the genome by adapting the in vitro method of DNA-Affinity Purification sequencing (DAP-seq) for N. crassa. To elucidate the regulatory network, we misexpressed each transcription factor in each upstream MAPK deletion mutant. Misexpression of adv-1 was sufficient to fully suppress the phenotype of the{Delta} pp-1 mutant and partially suppress the phenotype of the{Delta} mak-1 mutant. Collectively, our data demonstrate that the MAK-1-ADV-1 and MAK-2- PP-1 pathways form a tight regulatory network that maintains cell integrity and mediates communication and cell fusion.

genetics↗

bioRxiv2017

Asymmetric evolution of the transcription profiles and cis-regulatory sites contributes to the retention of transcription factor duplicates

Transcription factors (TFs) play a key role in regulating plant development and response to environmental stimuli. While most genes revert to single copy after a duplication event, transcription factors are retained at a significantly higher rate. However, it is unclear why TF duplicates have higher rates of retention relative to other genes. In this study, we compared three types of features (expression, sequence, and conservation) of retained TFs following whole genome duplication (WGD) events to genes with other functions, using Arabidopsis thaliana as a model. We found that gene function groups with higher maximum expression but lower mean expression tended to have higher duplicate retention rate post WGD, though TFs in particular are retained more often than would be expected based on the features examined. Conversely, expression of individual genes was not associated with duplication, but sequence conservation was. Furthermore, we found that the evolution of TF expression patterns and cis-regulatory cites favors the partitioning of ancestral states among the resulting duplicates. In particular, we found that one duplicate retains the majority of ancestral expression and cis-regulatory sites, while the \"non-ancestral\" duplicate was enriched for novel regulatory sites. To investigate how this pattern of partitioning pattern evolved, we modeled the retention of ancestral states in duplicate pairs using a system of differential equations. Our findings indicate that duplicate pairs evolve to a partitioned state more often than away from it, which in combination with accumulation of new regulatory sites in non-ancestral duplicates, suggest that selection favors partitioning via neofunctionalization.\n\nAuthor SummaryGene expression is controlled by regulatory proteins known as transcription factors. These factors control how an organism develops and responds to its environment. The evolution of transcription factor functions also contributes to the emergence of new species and crop domestication. In plants, new transcription factors mainly arise due to polyploidy, multiplication of the genome. Although most duplicated copies are lost following a genome duplication event, transcription factors are exceptional because they are often kept. Furthermore, we found that transcription factor duplicates that tend to diverge in how they are expressed and regulated in an unusual way where one copy mirrors the original, pre-duplication functional states of the ancestral gene, while the other loses the ancestral status and instead accumulates novel regulatory sites. Our results suggest these duplicate transcription factors may have been kept because one copy preserve ancestral function while the other has evolved new ones.

evolutionary biology↗