Search bioRxiv⌕ Search

Biology subjects

O'Connor, M. I.

Publications and source records attributed to O'Connor, M. I..

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Scaling temperature-dependent dispersal rates to metacommunity dynamics: An experimental test

O_LIChanges in community structure under shifting thermal regimes depend on how both local population dynamics and regional dispersal respond to temperature. Processes underlying dispersal, such as movement speed and density dependence, are constrained by temperature-dependent metabolic rates; however, the temperature dependence of population dispersal rate, and effect of this relationship on local and regional diversity patterns, have received little attention in the metabolic scaling literature. C_LIO_LIHere, we propose and experimentally test a framework that relates temperature effects on individual dispersal probability, to thermal performance curves (TPCs) for population dispersal rates, to colonization dynamics in metacommunities. Using multi-patch well plate microcosms, we measured thermal performance curves for dispersal rate in several naturally co-occurring ciliate species, and contrasted species-specific dispersal TPCs at different intra- and inter-specific densities and time scales. C_LIO_LIDispersal rate TPCs in monoculture differed at low versus high population densities, potentially suggesting distinct temperature effects on the density-independent (individual movement probability and speed) and density-dependent (quorum-sensing and resource competition) components of dispersal. C_LIO_LISpecies-specific dispersal rate TPCs in polyculture metacommunities explained differences in colonization dynamics across temperature treatments. Dispersal rate TPCs differed from intrinsic growth rate TPCs, such that better dispersers had higher-than-expected per capita population growth at the regional (whole-metacommunity) scale compared to predictions from standard growth TPCs measured in single-patch monoculture. C_LIO_LITogether, these results suggest that ignoring temperature-dependent dispersal can yield an incomplete understanding of biodiversity change in spatially structured systems exposed to warming. C_LI

ecology↗

Dispersal transiently modifies the temperature dependence of ecosystem productivity after an extreme thermal fluctuation

Effects of warming on ecosystem productivity are typically summarized over broad time scales, yet they emerge from communities that can reorganize in a matter of days. Temperature accelerates ecosystem productivity through predictable effects on metabolic rates, but dispersal across thermally heterogeneous metacommunities may modify this effect by redistributing communities and their underlying thermal phenotypes. Using multi-trophic freshwater mesocosm communities in which warming and dispersal were manipulated, we tested the hypothesis that increasing dispersal modifies the thermal sensitivity of gross primary productivity (GPP) through the redistribution of phytoplankton biomass, size spectra, and thermal phenotype composition along spatial thermal gradients. High dispersal temporarily weakened the thermal sensitivity of GPP after an unplanned heatwave. This effect was caused by reduced mass-specific GPP in the warmest mesocosms accompanied by regional homogenization of phytoplankton communities and the spread of poorly adapted thermal phenotypes under the highest dispersal treatments. Except immediately post-heatwave, the thermal sensitivity of GPP was robust to dispersal, despite evidence of metacommunity dynamics. These findings suggest that the temperature dependence of ecosystem metabolism can be briefly modified by dispersal after a perturbation, but remains robust under steady-state conditions.

ecology↗

Temperature-dependent herbivore nutritional traits affect population dynamics and persistence

The nutritional traits of herbivores affect demographic rates and regulate nutrient and energy fluxes among trophic levels. Herbivore nutritional requirements, and the nutrient contents of herbivore biomass, depend on temperature - at temperature extremes, more nutritious food is required to maximize growth rate and herbivore biomass contains fewer nutrients. Yet, the consequences of these thermal responses for the population dynamics of herbivore-autotroph systems have not been explored. Here, we develop and analyze a stoichiometrically-explicit, temperature-dependent model of herbivore-autotroph systems to answer the question: How does the thermal response of herbivore nutritional traits affect population responses to temperature and nutrient (phosphorus) supply? We find that temperature-dependent herbivore nutritional traits restrict the range of temperatures at which herbivore populations persist, reduce the stability of population dynamics at high phosphorus supplies, and limit the herbivores capacity to control autotroph population density. These results reflect temperature-dependent changes in the herbivores sensitivity to nutrient-poor autotroph biomass and ability to retain nutrients in biomass (and thereby dilute autotroph nutrient contents). The thermal response of herbivore nutritional traits may therefore be an important factor influencing population and community responses to warming and nutrient enrichment.

ecology↗

General predictions for the effects of warming on competition

Understanding the effects of climate change on ecological communities has been limited by a lack of general theory for how temperature affects competition. To fill this knowledge gap, we integrated Modern Coexistence Theory and the Metabolic Theory of Ecology by incorporating empirically-derived temperature sensitivities into Modern Coexistence Theorys central model. We then simulated warming in consumer-resource systems and found that warming reduced both niche and fitness differences, making species more ecologically similar and competitive interactions more neutral. The greatest shifts in competition occurred when temperature sensitivities among species were highly asymmetrical. Effects of warming on competition via niche differences were comparable to those on fitness differences, suggesting that the emphasis on vital rates in global change research may overlook key biodiversity drivers. This general theory expands the domains of two prominent ecological theories and provides predictions for how warming may alter competition even in benign regions of species thermal niches.

ecology↗

A general temperature dependence for biological nitrogen fixation across systems and levels of organization

Biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) provides half of global new nitrogen annually and plays an important role in biodiversity patterns and global biological carbon uptake processes. BNF rates accelerate with warming, with known implications for ecological functioning, yet the strength of this temperature sensitivity and its context dependence are not well understood. Here we synthesized 70 controlled experimental tests of the acute temperature dependence of nitrogen fixation rates and found that BNF rates accelerate with temperature in a consistent way across levels of biological organization from enzyme to community, mirroring scaling of metabolic temperature dependence across levels of organization for respiration, photosynthesis and methane production. This BNF temperature dependence is also remarkably consistent across biological systems. This analysis shows multiple lines of evidence for general, scalable effects of temperature on nitrogen fixation rates, in line with previous suggestions of a strong enzyme-level constraint. This widespread pattern may be important for understanding effects of warming on coupled carbon-nitrogen systems with ongoing global change.

ecology↗

Quantifying marine larval dispersal to assess MPA network connectivity and inform future national and transboundary planning efforts

A Marine Protected Area (MPA) network, in which multiple reserves are designated in a region, can promote the protection of biodiversity across space. To be effective as a network, the design must consider whether MPAs are likely to be connected through the movement of individuals of species of interest. Additionally, network design may explicitly incorporate design features that promote biodiversity in unprotected habitats through the dispersal or spillover of multiple species. Patterns of dispersal and the ability of MPAs to function as an interacting network, however, are difficult to estimate at broad and transboundary spatial scales, and therefore connectivity is often not fully integrated in the design and assessment of MPA networks. Here, we model the dispersal of multiple nearshore species to estimate the potential connectivity of the existing MPAs in British Columbia, Canada, including connections to MPAs in the United States by simulating dispersal using a biophysical model with regional oceanographic currents. We found that MPAs in BC potentially meet connectivity design criteria for nearshore invertebrate species: the majority of MPAs (65-90%) are likely to exchange individuals (i.e. functional connectivity) and support persistent metapopulations, and more than half the unprotected coast (55-85%) receives a large proportion of the larvae produced in MPAs. Furthermore, we found that species dispersal abilities and the level of exposure of an MPA to open ocean can predict dispersal distance when we account for the random effects of dispersal location and season. Therefore, future predictions of connectivity are possible based on these core biological and physical attributes, without running new simulations. Together, these analyses provide a robust and novel assessment of multi-species connectivity that can support the design of new MPAs with transboundary connectivity on the northwest coast of North America.

ecology↗

Abnormal weather drives disease outbreaks in wild and agricultural plants

Predicting effects of climate change on plant disease is critical for protecting ecosystems and food production. Climate change could exacerbate plant disease because parasites may be quicker to acclimate and adapt to novel climatic conditions than their hosts due to their smaller body sizes and faster generation times. Here we show how disease pressure responds to the anomalous weather that will increasingly occur with climate change by compiling a global database (5380 plant populations; 437 unique plant-disease combinations; 2,858,795 individual plant-disease samples) of disease incidence in both agricultural and wild plant systems. Because wild plant populations are assumed to be adapted to local climates, we hypothesized that large deviations from historical conditions would increase disease incidence. By contrast, since agricultural plants have been transported globally, we did not expect the historical climate where they are currently grown to be as predictive of disease incidence. Supporting these hypotheses, we found that disease outbreaks tended to occur during periods of warm temperatures in agricultural and cool-climate wild plant systems, but also occurred in warm-adapted wild (but not agricultural) plant systems experiencing anomalously cool weather. Outbreaks were additionally associated with higher rainfall in wild systems, especially those with historically wet climates. Our results suggest that historical climate affects susceptibility to disease for wild plant-disease systems, while warming drives risks for agricultural plant disease outbreaks regardless of historical climate.

ecology↗

Temperature dependence of competitive ability differs from that of growth rate

The effect of climate warming on future community composition is expected to be contingent on competitive outcomes, yet we currently lack mechanistic ecological understanding of how temperature affects competitive ability. Here, we combine resource competition theory with metabolic scaling theory and test hypotheses about how the temperature dependence of competitive ability changes with temperature. We find that the minimum resource requirement for growth, R* - an inverse indicator of competitive ability in phytoplankton - changes with temperature following a U-shaped pattern in all four species tested. The shape of temperature-dependence of competitive ability is systematically different from the temperature-dependence of population growth rates, both in our experiments and in collated data from previous studies. Our results suggest that exploitative competitive success is highest at temperatures that are sub-optimal for growth, and declines rapidly at both cold and warm ends of the thermal performance curve.

ecology↗

Temperature impacts on dengue incidence are nonlinear and mediated by climatic and socioeconomic factors

Temperature can influence mosquito-borne diseases like dengue. These effects are expected to vary geographically and over time in both magnitude and direction and may interact with other environmental variables, making it difficult to anticipate changes in response to climate change. Here, we investigate global variation in temperature-dengue relationship by analyzing published correlations between temperature and dengue and matching them with remotely sensed climatic and socioeconomic data. We found that the correlation between temperature and dengue was most positive at intermediate (near 24{degrees}C) temperatures, as predicted from the thermal biology of the mosquito and virus. Positive temperature-dengue associations were strongest when temperature variation and population density were high and decreased with infection burden and rainfall mean and variation, suggesting alternative limiting factors on transmission. Our results show that while climate effects on diseases are context-dependent they are also predictable from the thermal biology of transmission and its environmental and social mediators.

ecology↗

An improved species richness estimator using spatial abundance data

Species richness is an essential biodiversity variable indicative of ecosystem states and rates of invasion, speciation, and extinction both contemporarily and in fossil records. However, limited sampling effort and spatial aggregation of organisms mean that biodiversity surveys rarely observe every species in the survey area, which introduces bias to the estimated richness and inaccuracy to comparisons of communities across space and time. Here we present a nonparametric, asymptotic, and bias-corrected richness estimator,{Omega} T, by modelling how spatial abundance characteristics affect observation of species richness. We conduct simulation tests and applied{Omega} T to a tree census and a seaweed survey.{Omega} T consistently outperforms common estimators in balancing bias, precision, and difference detection accuracy. Our results provide theoretical insights into how natural and observer-induced variation affects species observation and support{Omega} T as a promising and application-ready richness estimator for a wide variety of data.

ecology↗

Macroecological variation in movement profiles: body size does not explain it all

Animals couple habitats by three types of movement: dispersal, migration, and foraging, which dynamically link populations, communities, and ecosystems. Spatial distances of movement tend to correlate with each other, reflecting shared allometric scaling with body size, but may diverge due to biomechanical, phylogenetic, and ecological constraints. While these constraints have been investigated within specific taxa, the macroecological and macroevolutionary constraints on movement distances, and causes of those constraints, are still unknown. Here, we synthesized distances of all three movement types across 300+ vertebrate species, and investigated how the relationships between movement types and body size were modified by movement medium, taxonomy, and trophic guild (carnivore, herbivore, etc.). We found that the strength of relationships between movement types and body size varied among environments, taxa, and trophic guilds. Movement profiles interacted with physiological, taxonomic, and ecological traits to depart from expected body mass scaling. Overall, we find that there are systematic patterns to movement distances, and that movement types with very distinct ecological consequences (foraging, migration) can be correlated and subject to similar constraints. This implies that the scales of population dynamics in ecological communities are not entirely determined by the environment and likely reflect general biomechanical, evolutionary and metabolic constraints.

ecology↗

Temperature effects on individual-level parasitism translate into predictable effects on parasitism in populations

Parasitism is expected to change in a warmer future, but whether warming leads to substantial increases in parasitism remains unclear. Understanding how warming effects on parasitism in individual hosts (e.g., parasite load) translate to effects on population-level parasitism (e.g., prevalence, R0) remains a major knowledge gap. We analyzed the temperature dependence of parasitism at both host and population levels in thirteen empirical vector-borne host-parasite systems and found a strong, significant positive correlation between the thermal optima of individual- and population-level parasitism. We also found a significant, positive correlation in eleven environmentally-transmitted parasite systems, though several of these systems exhibited thermal optima >5{o}C apart between individual and population levels. Similarly, parasitism thermal optima were close to host performance thermal optima in vector-borne systems but not in environmentally-transmitted systems. We then adapted and simulated simple models for both transmission modes and found a similar pattern to the empirical systems: thermal optima in vector-borne systems were more strongly correlated across scales compared to environmentally-transmitted systems. Generally, our results suggest that information on the temperature-dependence, and specifically the thermal optimum, at either the individual- or population-level should provide a useful--though not quantitatively exact--baseline for predicting temperature dependence at the other level, especially in vector-borne parasite systems. Environmentally-transmitted parasitism may operate by a different set of rules, in which temperature-dependence is decoupled in some systems, requiring the need for trait-based studies of temperature-dependence at individual and population levels.

ecology↗

Aquatic biodiversity enhances multiple nutritional benefits to humans

Humanity depends on biodiversity for health, well-being and a stable environment. As biodiversity change accelerates, we are still discovering the full range of consequences for human health and well-being. Here, we test the hypothesis -- derived from biodiversity - ecosystem functioning theory -- that species richness and ecological functional diversity allow seafood diets to fulfill multiple nutritional requirements, a condition necessary for human health. We analyzed a newly synthesized dataset of 7245 observations of nutrient and contaminant concentrations in 801 aquatic animal taxa, and found that species with different ecological traits have distinct and complementary micronutrient profiles, but little difference in protein content. The same complementarity mechanisms that generate positive biodiversity effects on ecosystem functioning in terrestrial ecosystems also operate in seafood assemblages, allowing more diverse diets to yield increased nutritional benefits independent of total biomass consumed. Notably, nutritional metrics that capture multiple micronutrients essential for human well-being depend more strongly on biodiversity than common ecological measures of function such as productivity, typically reported for grasslands and forests. Further, we found that increasing species richness did not increase the amount of protein in seafood diets, and also increased concentrations of toxic metal contaminants in the diet. Seafood-derived micronutrients are important for human health and are a pillar of global food and nutrition security. By drawing upon biodiversity-ecosystem functioning theory, we demonstrate that ecological concepts of biodiversity can deepen our understanding of natures benefits to people and unite sustainability goals for biodiversity and human well-being. Significance statementFood security is not simply about maintaining yields, it is also about the need for a stable supply of nutritionally diverse foods. Obtaining nutritious food is a major challenge facing humanity and diverse aquatic ecosystems can help meet this goal. To test how aquatic biodiversity affects human health, we assembled a new dataset of nutrients, contaminants and ecological traits of 801 aquatic species. We used ecological models to quantify the role of species richness and ecological functional diversity and found that these biodiversity dimensions enhanced seafood micronutrient provisioning by the same mechanisms that link biodiversity to productivity in grasslands, forests and other systems. Our results underscore the need to minimize aquatic biodiversity loss to sustain and improve human well-being.

ecology↗

Regional connectivity, local environmental conditions, and biotic interactions jointly structure a temperate seagrass epifaunal metacommunity

Ecological communities are jointly structured by dispersal, density-independent responses to environmental conditions and density-dependent biotic interactions. Metacommunity ecology provides a framework for understanding how these processes combine to determine community composition among local sites that are regionally connected through dispersal. In 17 temperate seagrass meadows along the British Columbia coast, we tested the hypothesis that eelgrass (Zostera marina L.) epifaunal invertebrate assemblages are influenced by local environmental conditions, but that high dispersal rates at larger spatial scales dampen effects of environmental differences. We used hierarchical joint species distribution modelling to understand the contribution of environmental conditions, spatial distance between meadows, and species co-occurrences to epifaunal invertebrate abundance and distribution across the region. We found that patterns of taxonomic compositional similarity among meadows were inconsistent with dispersal limitation and meadows in the same region were often no more similar to each other than meadows over 1000 km away. Abiotic environmental conditions (temperature, dissolved oxygen) explained a small fraction of variation in taxonomic abundances patterns across the region. We found novel co-occurrence patterns among taxa that could not be explained by shared responses to environmental gradients, suggesting the possibility that interspecific interactions influence seagrass invertebrate abundance and distribution. Our results add to mounting evidence that suggests that the biodiversity and ecosystem functions provided by seagrass meadows reflect ecological processes occurring both within meadows and across seascapes, and suggest that management of eelgrass habitat for biodiversity may be most effective when both local and regional processes are considered.

ecology↗

The shape of density dependence and the relationship between population growth, intraspecific competition and equilibrium population density

The logistic growth model is one of the most frequently used formalizations of density dependence affecting population growth, persistence and evolution. Ecological and evolutionary theory and applications to understand population change over time often include this model. However, the assumptions and limitations of this popular model are often not well appreciated. Here, we briefly review past use of the logistic growth model and highlight limitations by deriving population growth models from underlying consumer-resource dynamics. We show that the logistic equation likely is not applicable to many biological systems. Rather, density-regulation functions are usually non-linear and may exhibit convex or both concave and convex curvatures depending on the biology of resources and consumers. In simple cases, the dynamics can be fully described by the continuous-time Beverton-Holt model. More complex consumer dynamics show similarities to a Maynard Smith-Slatkin model. Importantly, we show how population-level parameters, such as intrinsic rates of increase and equilibrium population densities are not independent, as often assumed. Rather, they are functions of the same underlying parameters. The commonly assumed positive relationship between equilibrium population density and competitive ability is typically invalid. As a solution, we propose simple and general relationships between intrinsic rates of increase and equilibrium population densities that capture the essence of different consumer-resource systems. Relating population level models to underlying mechanisms allows us to discuss applications to evolutionary outcomes and how these models depend on environmental conditions, like temperature via metabolic scaling. Finally, we use time-series from microbial food chains to fit population growth models and validate theoretical predictions. Our results show that density-regulation functions need to be chosen carefully as their shapes will depend on the study systems biology. Importantly, we provide a mechanistic understanding of relationships between model parameters, which has implications for theory and for formulating biologically sound and empirically testable predictions.

ecology↗

Nonlinear averaging of thermal experience predicts population growth rates in a thermally variable environment

As thermal regimes change worldwide, projections of future population and species persistence often require estimates of how population growth rates depend on temperature. These projections rarely account for how temporal variation in temperature can systematically modify growth rates relative to projections based on constant temperatures. Here, we tested the hypothesis that population growth rates in fluctuating thermal environments differ from growth rates in constant conditions, and that the differing thermal performance curves (TPCs) can be predicted quantitatively. With experimental populations of the green alga Tetraselmis tetrahele, we show that nonlinear averaging techniques accurately predicted increased as well as decreased population growth rates in fluctuating thermal regimes relative to constant thermal regimes. We extrapolate from these results to project critical temperatures for population growth and persistence of 89 phytoplankton species in naturally variable thermal environments. These results advance our ability to predict population dynamics in the context of global change.

ecology↗

A temperature dependent trophic cascade modifies temperature dependence of ecosystem function

Ecological communities and their ecosystem functions are sensitive to temperature, and aquatic habitats worldwide continue to experience unprecedented warming. Understanding ecological effects of warming requires linking empirical evidence to theories that allow projection to unobserved conditions. Metabolic scaling theory and its tests suggest that warming accelerates ecosystem functions (e.g., oxygen flux), yet this prediction apparently contradicts community-level studies suggesting warming is a stressor that can reduce ecosystem function. We sought to reconcile these predictions with an experimental test of the hypothesis that cascading trophic interactions modify the temperature-dependence of community structure and ecosystem fluxes. In a series of independent freshwater ecosystems exposed to a thermal gradient, we found that warmer temperatures strengthened the trophic cascade increased and indirectly changed community structure by altering grazer species composition and phytoplankton biomass. Temperature-driven community shifts only modestly affected the temperature dependence of net ecosystem oxygen fluxes. Over the 10 {degrees}C thermal gradient, NPP and ER increased [~]2.7-fold among ecosystems, while standing phytoplankton biomass declined by 85-95%. The exponential increase in oxygen flux over the thermal gradient, as well as monotonic declines in phytoplankton standing stock, suggested no threshold effects of warming across systems. We also observed temperature variation over time, within ecosystems. For phytoplankton biomass, temporal variation had the opposite effect to spatial variation, suggesting that within-community temporal change in community structure was not predicted by space-for-time substitution. We conclude that food chain length can modify effects of temperature on ecosystem fluxes, but that temperature can still have continuous and positive effects on ecosystem fluxes, consistent with patterns based on large-scale, macroecological comparisons. Changes in community structure, including temperature dependent trophic cascades, may be compatible with prevailing and predictable effects of temperature on ecosystem functions related to fundamental effects of temperature on metabolism.\n\nStatement of authorshipJG & MIO designed the study, MIO & US provided materials, JG & SJC performed research and collected data, JG performed zooplankton analysis, SJC performed phytoplankton analysis, JG & MIO performed modeling work, analyzed data output, and wrote the first draft, and all authors contributed substantially to reviews

ecology↗

An empirical test of the temperature dependence of carrying capacity

Predicting population persistence and dynamics in the context of global change is a major challenge for ecology. A widely held prediction is that population abundance at carrying capacity decreases with warming, assuming no change in resource supply, due to increased individual resource demands associated with higher metabolic rates. However, this prediction, which is based on metabolic scaling theory (MST), has not been tested empirically. Here we experimentally tested whether effects of temperature on short-term metabolic performance (rates of photosynthesis and respiration) translate directly to effects of temperature on population rates in a phytoplankton species. We found that effects of temperature on organismal metabolic rates matched theoretical predictions, and that the temperature dependence of individual metabolic performance translated to population abundance. Population abundance at carrying capacity, K, decreased with temperature less than expected based on the temperature dependence of photosynthesis. Concurrent with declines in abundance, we observed a linear decline in cell size of approximately 2.3% {degrees}C-1, which is consistent with broadly observed patterns in unicellular organisms, known as the temperature-size rule. When theoretical predictions include higher densities allowed by shifts toward smaller individual size, observed declines in K were quantitatively consistent with theoretical predictions. Our results indicate that outcomes of population dynamics across a range of temperatures reflect organismal responses to temperature via metabolic scaling, providing a general basis for forecasting population responses to global change.

ecology↗