What shapes intraspecific genetic diversity in amphibians and reptiles? A comparative macrogenetic study across six biogeographic regions
Aim: Given that much of Earth's biodiversity is contained within species, inferring intraspecific genetic diversity and identifying its ecological correlates is essential for understanding evolutionary processes and informing conservation. Here, we investigate broad-scale variation in species-level mitochondrial genetic diversity and evaluate the relative importance of alternative ecological hypotheses proposed to explain it. Location: Brazilian Atlantic Forest, Iberian Peninsula, northwestern Africa, Arabian Peninsula, Madagascar and Australian Monsoonal Tropics. Taxon: Amphibians and reptiles Methods: We assembled a comprehensive dataset by integrating and manually curating mitochondrial sequences, occurrence records, environmental data and species traits from multiple open-access sources. We used multiple mitochondrial genes to estimate mean nucleotide diversity for each study species and quantified regional variation in genetic diversity. We then used random forests models to evaluate the relative importance of selected variables representing hypotheses related to water-energy availability, topography, historical climatic stability, land-cover characteristics, species geographic characteristics, life-history traits, evolutionary history and conservation status. Results: The final dataset comprised 247 amphibians and 295 reptiles, for which 43 and 52 explanatory variables were evaluated, respectively. Overall, the strongest support was found for hypotheses related to life-history traits, topographic heterogeneity and water-energy availability. In amphibians, higher genetic diversity was associated with smaller body size and greater environmental heterogeneity, particularly broader elevational and precipitation gradients. In reptiles, genetic diversity was primarily associated with life-history traits, with species of smaller body size and lower reproductive output exhibiting higher diversity. Long-term climatic stability showed comparatively little explanatory power for both taxa. Main conclusions: Our comprehensive study demonstrates that integrating extensive manual data curation with comparative macrogenetic analyses provides a robust framework for identifying broad-scale ecological correlates of mitochondrial genetic diversity. These findings improve our understanding of the factors associated with contemporary patterns of genetic diversity and provide a foundation for future conservation assessments in data-limited systems.