Biology subjects

MacDonald, J.

Publications and source records attributed to MacDonald, J..

23 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

bioRxiv2021

Microbiome differential abundance methods produce disturbingly different results across 38 datasets

Identifying differentially abundant microbes is a common goal of microbiome studies. Multiple methods have been applied for this purpose, which are largely used interchangeably in the literature. Although it has been observed that these tools can produce different results, there have been very few large-scale comparisons to describe the scale and significance of these differences. In addition, it is challenging for microbiome researchers to know which differential abundance tools are appropriate for their study and how these tools compare to one another. Here, we have investigated these questions by analyzing 38 16S rRNA gene datasets with two sample groups for differential abundance testing. We tested for differences in amplicon sequence variants and operational taxonomic units (referred to as ASVs for simplicity) between these groups with 14 commonly used differential abundance tools. Our findings confirmed that these tools identified drastically different numbers and sets of significant ASVs, however, for many tools the number of features identified correlated with aspects of the tested study data, such as sample size, sequencing depth, and effect size of community differences. We also found that the ASVs identified by each method were dependent on whether the abundance tables were prevalence-filtered before testing. ALDEx2 and ANCOM produced the most consistent results across studies and agreed best with the intersect of results from different approaches. In contrast, several methods, such as LEfSe, limma voom, and edgeR, produced inconsistent results and in some cases were unable to control the false discovery rate. In addition to these observations, we were unable to find supporting evidence for a recent recommendation that limma voom, corncob, and DESeq2 are more reliable overall compared with other methods. Although ALDEx2 and ANCOM are two promising conservative methods, we argue that those researchers requiring more sensitive methods should use a consensus approach based on multiple differential abundance methods to help ensure robust biological interpretations.

bioinformatics↗

bioRxiv2020

Direct information estimation from cryo-EM Movies with CARYON

While cryo-EM with modern direct electron detectors has proven incredibly powerful, becoming a dominant technique in structural biology, the analysis of cryo-EM images is significantly complicated by their exceptionally low signal-to-noise ratio, limiting the accuracy of the parameterisation of the physical models required for successful classification and reconstruction. Micrographs from modern direct electron detectors are typically collected as dose-fractionated multi-frame movies to allow the recording of separated individual electron impacts. These detectors improve electron detection and allow for both inter-frame motion correction, and dose-dependent image filtering, lessening the overall impact of effects deleterious to the recovery of high-resolution information. In this study we measured the information content at each spatial frequency in cryo-EM movies as it accrues during the course of an exposure. We show that, as well as correction for motion and radiation damage, the use of the information within movies allows substantially improved direct estimation of the remaining key image parameters required for accurate 3D reconstruction: the image CTF and spectral SNR. We are developing "CARYON" {insert contrived acronym here}, as a LAFTER-family filter for cryo-EM movies based upon such measurements. CARYON is intended to provide the best parameter estimation and filtration possible for a single complete, or large sub-section from a, movie micrograph without the use of a previously refined density. We demonstrate its utility in both single-particle and tomographic cryo-EM data processing.

biophysics↗

bioRxiv2020

An evolutionarily acquired microRNA shapes development of mammalian cortical projections

The corticospinal tract is unique to mammals and the corpus callosum is unique to placental mammals (eutherians). The emergence of these structures is thought to underpin the evolutionary acquisition of complex motor and cognitive skills. Corticospinal motor neurons (CSMN) and callosal projection neurons (CPN) are the archetypal projection neurons of the corticospinal tract and corpus callosum, respectively. Although a number of conserved transcriptional regulators of CSMN and CPN development have been identified in vertebrates, none are unique to mammals and most are co-expressed across multiple projection neuron subtypes. Here, we discover seventeen CSMN-enriched microRNAs (miRNAs), fifteen of which map to a single genomic cluster that is exclusive to eutherians. One of these, miR-409-3p, promotes CSMN subtype identity in part via repression of LMO4, a key transcriptional regulator of CPN development. In vivo, miR-409-3p is sufficient to convert deep-layer CPN into CSMN. This is the first demonstration of an evolutionarily acquired miRNA in eutherians that refines cortical projection neuron subtype development. Our findings implicate miRNAs in the eutherians increase in neuronal subtype and projection diversity, the anatomic underpinnings of their complex behavior. Significance StatementThe mammalian central nervous system contains unique projections from the cerebral cortex thought to underpin complex motor and cognitive skills, including the corticospinal tract and corpus callosum. The neurons giving rise to these projections - corticospinal and callosal projection neurons - develop from the same progenitors, but acquire strikingly different fates. The broad evolutionary conservation of known genes controlling cortical projection neuron fates raises the question of how the more narrowly conserved corticospinal and callosal projections evolved. We identify a microRNA cluster selectively expressed by corticospinal projection neurons and exclusive to placental mammals. One of these microRNAs promotes corticospinal fate via regulation of the callosal gene LMO4, suggesting a mechanism whereby microRNA regulation during development promotes evolution of neuronal diversity.

neuroscience↗

bioRxiv2020

GO-CRISPR: a highly controlled workflow to discover gene essentiality in loss-of-function screens

Genome-wide CRISPR screens are an effective discovery tool for genes that underlie diverse cellular mechanisms that can be scored through cell fitness. Loss-of-function screens are particularly challenging compared to gain-of-function because of the limited dynamic range of decreased sgRNA sequence detection. Here we describe Guide-Only control CRISPR (GO-CRISPR), an improved loss-of-function screening workflow, and its companion software package, Toolset for the Ranked Analysis of GO-CRISPR Screens (TRACS). We demonstrate a typical GO-CRISPR workflow in a non-proliferative 3D spheroid model of dormant high grade serous ovarian cancer and demonstrate superior performance to standard screening methods. The unique integration of the pooled sgRNA library quality and guide-only controls allows TRACS to identify novel molecular pathways that were previously unidentified in tumor dormancy. Together, GO-CRISPR and TRACS can robustly improve the discovery of essential genes in challenging biological scenarios.

systems biology↗

bioRxiv2019

Inherited duplications of PPP2R3B promote naevi and melanoma via a novel C21orf91-driven proliferative phenotype

The majority of the heredity of melanoma remains unexplained, however inherited copy number changes have not yet been systematically studied. The genetic environment is highly relevant to treatment stratification, and new gene discovery is therefore desirable. Using an unbiased whole genome screening approach for copy number we identify here a novel melanoma predisposing factor, familial duplications of gene PPP2R3B, encoding a regulatory unit of critical phosphatase PP2A. Significant correlation between expression of PPP2R3B in tumour tissue and survival in a large melanoma cohort was confirmed, and associated with a non-immunological expression profile. Mechanistically, construction and extensive characterization of a stable, inducible cellular model for PPP2R3B overexpression revealed induction of pigment cell switching towards proliferation and away from migration. Importantly, this was independent of the known microphthalmia-associated transcription factor (MITF)-controlled pigment cell phenotype switch, and was instead driven by uncharacterised gene C21orf91. Bioinformatic studies point to C21orf91as a novel target of MITF, and therefore a potential hub in the control of phenotype switching in melanoma. This study identifies novel germline copy number variants in PPP2R3B predisposing to melanocytic neoplasia, and uncovers a new potential therapeutic target C21orf91 in the control of pigment cell proliferation.

genomics↗