Biology subjects

Janicke, T.

Publications and source records attributed to Janicke, T..

10 recordsLinked to original sources

bioRxiv2026

Sexual selection does not predict long-term population trends in birds

Sexual selection is a major evolutionary force, yet its demographic consequences remain unclear. While experimental studies often report positive effects of sexual selection on traits linked to population performance, comparative studies often find null or negative associations with population persistence. One explanation for this discrepancy is that the demographic consequences of sexual selection depend on ecological context, particularly variation in mortality and fecundity. Here, we used six decades of abundance data and test whether sexual selection predicts population trends across 738 bird species from Europe and North America. We quantify sexual selection using complementary proxies capturing different components of sexual selection: mating system, sexual dichromatism, sexual size dimorphism and relative testes mass. We further assess whether the effect of sexual selection in population trends is mediated by mortality and fecundity. Across all proxies, we found no evidence that sexual selection is associated with population trends. This result is consistent across continents and robust to variation in mortality and fecundity. Our findings suggest that, despite its central role in shaping phenotypic evolution, sexual selection does not translate into consistent effects on long-term population trends at macroecological scales. More broadly, these results highlight a potential disconnect between evolutionary processes and population dynamics.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2025

Pollinator abundance shapes sexual selection in an angiosperm

Sexual selection is a cornerstone of evolutionary biology potentially operating in all sexually-reproducing organisms. Modern developments in the field revealed that this selective force extends beyond Darwins initial focus on access to mates in terms of competition for access to gametes of the other sex. Despite its presumed universality, sexual selection theory remains largely untested in plants compared to animals. This gap may partly stem from challenges in quantifying sexual selection using approaches that account for a critical plant-specific factor: the reliance on pollinators as third-party agents for accessing mates. Here, we quantified sexual selection along consecutive episodes of selection in the hermaphroditic plant Brassica rapa by integrating the monitoring of pollinator movements with genetic paternity analyses in experimental populations. Our approach identifies pollen competition for ovules as the primary arena for sexual selection in B. rapa. Darwinian competition for access to mates constitutes a secondary force, and was stronger in the male compared to the female sex function, as predicted by classic theory. Importantly, experimentally induced variation in pollinator abundance modulated the balance between pre- and post-pollination sexual selection. Under reduced pollinator abundance, the opportunity for selection on mate acquisition increased. Crucially, we demonstrate that ignoring pollinator movements among plants leads to erroneous quantification of pre-pollination sexual selection. We argue that a unifying theory of sexual selection requires a more comprehensive quantification of pre- and post-pollination episodes of selection, taking into account the specificities of gamete transfer in plants.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2024

Simulations provide a mechanistic interpretation of Bateman gradients

The Bateman gradient (BG or ) is a fundamental metric of sexual selection, and is often interpreted as the fitness advantage individuals can gain by increasing their number of mates. However, researchers commonly misconceive the relationship between mating success (MS) and reproductive success (RS) as always being causal, leading to a misinterpretation of the BG. The BG is phenomenological and therefore uninformative about the mechanisms leading to correlations between MS and RS. Here, we simulate sequential matings in males from biological systems with varying levels of anisogamy and sperm competition, to better understand the underlying processes that modulate male BGs. We show that the BG does not solely reflect the causal influence of MS on RS as is typically interpreted, but is also a consequence of covariances between male MS and male ejaculate traits, female fecundity, or female post-mating decisions. For example, we show that the BG is substantially shallower when the ejaculate size of males negatively co-varies with their MS, such as in species with alternative male reproductive tactics. Such covariances can lead to a misinterpretation of the measured BG, because here, it does not merely represent the strength of selection on intra-sexual competition for mates. We suggest how such covariances can be visually assessed, and accounted for using partial Bateman gradients, to better interpret the influence of MS on RS, thus the strength of pre-copulatory sexual selection. Among other simplifications, our simulations have a male-only focus, but they provide insights into the mechanisms driving inter- and intra-specific variation in the BG, clarify its meaning, and improve our understand of sexual selection.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2024

The acoustic adaptation hypothesis across terrestrial vertebrates: a meta-analysis

Acoustic communication plays a prominent role in various ecological and evolutionary processes involving social interactions. The properties of acoustic signals are thought to be influenced not only by the interaction between signaller and receiver but also by the acoustic characteristics of the environment through which the signal is transmitted. This conjecture forms the core of the so-called "acoustic adaptation hypothesis" (AAH), which posits that vegetation structure affects frequency and temporal parameters of acoustic signals emitted by a signaller as a function of their acoustic degradation properties. Specifically, animals in densely vegetated closed habitats are expected to produce longer acoustic signals with lower repetition rates and lower frequencies (minimum, mean, maximum, and peak) compared to the ones inhabiting less vegetated open habitats. To date, this hypothesis has received mixed results, with the level of support depending on the taxonomic group and the methodology used. We conducted a systematic literature search of empirical studies testing for an effect of vegetation structure on acoustic signalling and assessed the generality of the AAH using a meta-analytic approach based on 371 effect sizes from 75 studies and 57 taxa encompassing birds, mammals and amphibians. Overall, our results do not provide consistent support for the AAH, neither in within-species comparisons (suggesting no overall phenotypically plastic response of acoustic signalling to vegetation structure) nor in among-species comparisons (suggesting no overall evolutionary response). However, when considering birds only, we found a weak support for the AAH in within-species comparisons, which was mainly driven by studies that measured frequency bandwidth, suggesting that this variable may exhibit a phenotypically plastic response to vegetation structure. For among-species comparisons in birds, we also found support for the AAH, but this effect was not significant after excluding comparative studies that did not account for phylogenetic non-independence. Collectively, our synthesis does not support a universal role of vegetation structure in the evolution of acoustic communication. We highlight the need for more empirical work on currently under-studied taxa such as amphibians, mammals, and insects. Furthermore, we propose a framework for future research on the AAH. We specifically advocate for a more detailed and quantitative characterization of habitats to identify frequencies with the highest detection probability and to determine if frequencies with greater detection distances are preferentially used. Finally, we stress that empirical tests of the AAH should focus on signals which are selected for increased transmission distance.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2023

Sperm competition favours intermediate sperm size in a hermaphrodite

Sperm competition is a potent mechanism of post-copulatory sexual selection that has been found to shape reproductive morphologies and behaviours in promiscuous animals. Especially sperm size has been argued to evolve in response to sperm competition through its effect on sperm longevity, sperm motility, the ability to displace competing sperm and ultimately fertilization success. Additionally, sperm size has been observed to co-evolve with female reproductive morphology. Theoretical work predicts that sperm competition may select for longer sperm but may also favour shorter sperm if sperm size trades off with number. In this study, we studied the relationship between sperm size and post-mating success in the free-living flatworm, Macrostomum lignano. Specifically, we used inbred isolines of M. lignano that varied in sperm size to investigate how sperm size translated into the ability of worms to transfer and deposit sperm in a mating partner. Our results revealed a hump-shaped relationship with individuals producing sperm of intermediate size having highest sperm competitiveness. This finding broadens our understanding of the evolution of sperm morphology by providing empirical support for stabilizing selection on sperm size under sperm competition.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2023

Resolving the climatic and ecological drivers of geographical gradients in avian sexual selection

Sexual selection, one of the central pillars of evolutionary theory, has powerful effects on organismal morphology, behaviour and population dynamics. However, current knowledge about geographical variation in this evolutionary mechanism and its underlying drivers remains highly incomplete, in part because standardized data on the strength of sexual selection is sparse even for well-studied organisms. Here we use information on mating systems - including the incidence of polygamy and extra-pair paternity - to quantify the intensity of sexual selection in 10671 (>99.9%) bird species distributed worldwide. We show that avian sexual selection varies latitudinally, peaking at higher latitudes, although the gradient is reversed in the worlds most sexually selected birds - specialist frugivores - which are strongly associated with tropical forests. Phylogenetic models further reveal that the strength of sexual selection is explained by temperature seasonality coupled with a suite of climate-associated factors, including migration, diet, and territoriality. Overall, these analyses suggest that climatic conditions leading to short, intense breeding seasons, or highly abundant and patchy food resources, increase the potential for polygamy in birds, driving latitudinal gradients in sexual selection. Our findings help to resolve longstanding debates about spatial variation in evolutionary mechanisms linked to reproductive biology, and provide a comprehensive species-level dataset for further studies of selection and phenotypic evolution in the context of global climatic change.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2022

Sexual selection moderates heat stress response in males and females

A widespread effect of climate change is the displacement of organisms from their thermal optima. The associated thermal stress imposed by climate change has been argued to have a particularly strong impact on male reproduction but evidence for this postulated sex-specific stress response is equivocal. One important factor that may explain intra- and interspecific variation in stress responses is sexual selection, which is predicted to magnify negative effects of stress. Nevertheless, empirical studies exploring the interplay of sexual selection and heat stress are still scarce. We tested experimentally for an interaction between sexual selection and thermal stress in the red flour beetle Tribolium castaneum by contrasting heat responses in male and female reproductive success between setups of enforced monogamy versus polygamy. We found that polygamy magnifies detrimental effects of heat stress in males but relaxes the observed negative effects in females. Our results suggest that sexual selection can reverse sex differences in thermal sensitivity, and may therefore alter sex-specific selection on alleles associated with heat tolerance. We argue that these findings have important implications for predicting the role of sexual selection for the adaptation to current global warming and increased frequency of extreme climatic events.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2021

Sexual selection in females across the animal tree of life

The pioneers of sexual selection theory proposed that males are generally eager whereas females are rather coy with respect to mating. This male-centred perspective on sexual selection continues to permeate our perception of sex differences across disciplines. Despite an increased awareness that females also compete for mating partners, we still tend to consider sexual selection in females a rare peculiarity. Here we present meta-analytic evidence from 72 species across a broad range of animal taxa to show that sexual selection in females is widespread and should be considered the norm rather than the exception. Thereby, our results extend our general understanding of sexual reproduction and may contribute to a more balanced perspective of how sexual selection operates in both males and females.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2021

Sexual selection and sexual size dimorphism in animals

Sexual selection is often considered as a critical evolutionary force promoting sexual size dimorphism (SSD) in animals. However, empirical evidence for a positive relationship between sexual selection on males and male-biased SSD received mixed support depending on the studied taxonomic group and on the method used to quantify sexual selection. Here, we present a meta-analytic approach accounting for phylogenetic non-independence to test how standardized metrics of the opportunity and strength of pre-copulatory sexual selection relate to SSD across a broad range of animal taxa comprising up to 102 effect sizes from 64 species. We found that SSD was correlated with the sex difference in the opportunity for sexual selection but not with the sex difference in the Bateman gradient. These findings suggest that pre-copulatory sexual selection plays a limited role for the evolution of sexual size dimorphism in a broad phylogenetic context.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2021

Stronger net selection on males across animals

Sexual selection is considered the major driver for the evolution of manifold sex differences. However, the eco-evolutionary dynamics of sexual selection and their role for a populations adaptive potential to respond to environmental change have only recently been explored. Theory predicts that sexual selection promotes adaptation at a low demographic cost only if net selection is stronger on males compared to females. We used a comparative approach to show that net selection is indeed stronger in males in species prone to intense sexual selection. Given that both sexes share the vast majority of their genes, our findings corroborate the notion that the genome is often confronted with a more stressful environment when expressed in males. Collectively, our study supports a long-standing key assumption required for sexual selection to bolster adaptation, and intense sexual selection may therefore enable some species to track environmental change more efficiently. One sentence summaryComparative study finds support for stronger net selection in males.

evolutionary biology↗