Reinforcement influences the ability of cryptic female choice to exert conspecific sperm precedence in hybridizing Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) and brown trout (Salmo trutta)
Conspecific sperm precedence via cryptic female choice is a post-ejaculatory selection process that reduces hybridization, and can be pronounced in sympatric species. In their native Europe, Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) and brown trout (Salmo trutta) exert conspecific sperm precedence under heterospecific sperm competition, which is at least partially enabled by female reproductive fluid. We examined post-ejaculatory selection of both species in Newfoundland, Canada, where Atlantic salmon evolved in absence of brown trout, but now experience hybridization threats due to anthropogenic introductions. Using split-ejaculate and split-clutch in-vitro fertilizations we evaluated whether allopatric evolution has relaxed this selection in Atlantic salmon, and found that they had no ability to bias paternity towards conspecific males, whereas naturalized brown trout retained a strong ability to do so. Female reproductive fluid influenced this, as when fluid associated with a species eggs was swapped, hybridization increased. In the artificial situation of no female reproductive fluid during sperm competition, paternity changed dramatically, but sperm swimming performance did not predict it. Our findings contribute to understanding the evolution of cryptic female choice and how the mechanisms of reproductive isolation can be reinforced through sympatry, while also highlighting a new potential conservation concern for North American Atlantic salmon.