A Comparison of Skeletal Muscle Diffusion Tensor Imaging Tractography Seeding Methods
The internal arrangement of a muscles fibers with respect to its mechanical line of action (muscle architecture) is a major determinant of muscle function. Muscle architecture can be quantified using diffusion tensor magnetic resonance imaging-based tractography, which propagates streamlines from a set of seed points by integrating vectors that represent the direction of greatest water diffusion (and by inference, the local fiber orientation). Previous work has demonstrated that tractography outcomes are sensitive to the method for defining seed points, but this sensitivity has not been fully examined. To do so, we developed a realistic simulated muscle architecture and implemented four novel methods for tract seeding: seeding along the muscle-aponeurosis boundary with an updated procedure for rounding seed points prior to lookup in the muscle boundary mask and diffusion tensor matrix (APO-3); voxel-based seeding throughout the muscle volume at a user-specified spatial frequency (VXL-1); voxel-based seeding throughout the muscle volume at a variable spatial frequency (VXL-2), and seeding near external and internal muscle boundaries (VXL-3). We then implemented these methods in an example human dataset. The updated aponeurosis seeding procedures allow more accurate and robust tract propagation from seed points. The voxel-based seeding methods had quantification outcomes that closely matched the updated aponeurosis seeding method. Further, the voxel-based methods can accelerate the overall workflow and may be beneficial in high throughput analysis of multi-muscle datasets. Continued evaluation of these methods in a wider range of muscle architectures is warranted.