Duah-Gyamfi, A. | Search bioRxiv

bioRxiv2024

Why models underestimate tropical forest productivity: a case study in West Africa

Tropical forests dominate terrestrial photosynthesis, yet there are major contradictions in our understanding due to a lack of field studies, especially outside the tropical Americas. A recent field study indicated that West African forests have among the highest forests gross primary productivity (GPP) yet observed, contradicting models that rank them lower than Amazonian forests. Here, we explore possible reasons for this data-model mismatch. We found the in situ GPP measurements higher than multiple global GPP products at the studied sites in Ghana. The underestimation of GPP by models largely disappears when a standard photosynthesis model is informed by local field-measured values of (a) fractional absorbed photosynthetic radiation (fAPAR), and (b) photosynthetic traits. Satellites systematically underestimate fAPAR in the tropics due to cloud contamination issues. The study highlights the potential widespread underestimation of tropical forests GPP and carbon cycling and hints at the ways forward for model and input data improvement. Related manuscriptThe recent field study mentioned above is a manuscript currently accepted by Nature Communications (manuscript id NCOMMS-23-37419), which is available as a preprint https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-3136892/v1 Codes and data availabilityAll data and codes underlying the study are currently shared via Github (link here) which will be made available through Zenodo upon acceptance.

ecology↗

bioRxiv2023

Contrasting carbon cycle along tropical forest aridity gradients in W Africa and Amazonia

2Tropical forests cover large areas of equatorial Africa and play a significant role in the global carbon cycle. However, there has been a lack of in-situ measurements to understand the forests gross and net primary productivity (GPP and NPP) and their allocation. Here we present the first detailed field assessment of the carbon budget of multiple forest sites in Africa, by monitoring 14 one-hectare plots along an aridity gradient in Ghana. When compared with an equivalent aridity gradient in Amazonia using the same measurement protocol, the studied West African forests generally had higher GPP and NPP and lower carbon use efficiency (CUE). The West African aridity gradient consistently shows the highest NPP, CUE, GPP, and autotrophic respiration at a medium-aridity site, Bobiri. Notably, NPP and GPP of the site are the highest yet reported anywhere in the tropics using similar methods. Widely used data products (MODIS and FLUXCOM) substantially underestimate productivity when compared to in situ measurements, in Amazonia and especially in Africa. Our analysis suggests that the high productivity of the African forests is linked to their large GPP allocation to canopy and semi-deciduous characteristics, which may be a result of a seasonal climate coupled with high soil fertility.

ecology↗