Gene-Culture Coevolution Favours the Emergence of Traditions in Mate Choice through Conformist Social Learning
The emergence of cultural traditions has long been considered to depend on sophisticated social learning mechanisms, particularly conformist transmission exhibiting a disproportionate bias towards majority behaviours. We challenge this assumption by demonstrating that gene-culture coevolutionary dynamics can fundamentally alter the conditions required for tradition formation, especially in the context of mate choice. Using simulation models of mate choice where female preferences are socially transmitted and male traits are genetically inherited, we show that the interaction between cultural and genetic transmission creates novel evolutionary dynamics. In a first model (the Cultural Model) representing classical cultural evolution scenarios, we show that traditions emerge only when conformity disproportionately amplifies majority behaviours. In a second model (the Gene-Culture Model), we introduce a distinction between learned behaviours and realized behaviours and show that when mate choice depends on both conformist learning and male trait availability, even simple social learning strategies can establish persistent traditions. In this context, majority exaggeration is no longer a necessary property of social learning for traditions to arise. This occurs because positive frequency-dependent interactions between preference and trait dynamics provide an additional mechanism that reinforces majority behaviours beyond conformist learning. Our findings have broader implications for cultural evolution theory, suggesting that many behaviours that depend on resource availability may exhibit tradition-like patterns under less stringent social learning conditions than previously assumed. By distinguishing between preference and choice, and demonstrating the importance of gene-culture interactions, this study advocates for more integrated approaches to understanding cultural evolution that consider the interplay between multiple inheritance systems.