Search bioRxiv⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Davidson, N. R.

Publications and source records attributed to Davidson, N. R..

11 recordsLinked to original sources

Cross-assay RNA modeling reveals cancer biomarkers

The clinical heterogeneity of cancer poses a major challenge for precision medicine. Limited cohort sizes across evolving assay platforms impede reliable biomarker discovery. Here, we systematically evaluate how to integrate data from four transcriptomics platforms: bulk and single-cell (sc) RNA sequencing (RNA-seq), NanoString, and microarray for predictive modeling in cancer. We use high-grade serous carcinoma (HGSC) of tube-ovarian origin as a model system, as it is highly heterogeneous in both biology and assay data. We find that using fold-change of gene expression in patients with matched pre- and post-neoadjuvant chemotherapy samples reduces inter-patient and inter-assay variability but is insufficient to overcome platform-specific biases. Microarray and scRNA-seq data exhibit systematic biases, while RNA-seq and NanoString show the most promise for combination into a single training cohort. To mitigate inter-assay limitations, we generate a new data set of HGSC tumor samples profiled with both RNA-seq and NanoString, and use it to identify the limits of detection and optimal harmonization strategies. Our approaches enable integration of cohorts for separate and combined RNA-seq and NanoString predictive models of disease recurrence (test-set AUROCs > 0.8), validated in external microarray cohorts. We leverage single-cell and bulk RNA-seq network-based analyses to provide mechanistic context for genes in the predictive models. Our models indicate that GBP4 expression is a key predictor of recurrence and marks immune remodeling towards cytotoxicity. We provide an interactive web portal to facilitate exploration of data and results. These findings guide cross-assay harmonization of transcriptomic data and enable improved predictive modeling in heterogeneous cancers. Statement of SignificanceWe present a framework for integrating RNA-seq, NanoString, microarray, and single-cell transcriptomic data for predictive modeling, enabling robust biomarker discovery in heterogeneous cancers and identifying GBP4 as a marker of immune remodeling.

bioinformatics↗

Transcriptomic subtypes in high-grade serous ovarian cancer are driven by tumor cellular composition

High-grade serous ovarian carcinoma (HGSC) is an aggressive malignancy for which bulk transcriptomic subtypes are used to stratify tumors, interpret biology, and guide biomarker development. The four TCGA-derived subtypes, mesenchymal (C1.MES), immunoreactive (C2.IMM), proliferative (C5.PRO), and differentiated (C4.DIF), are consistently observed across cohorts. However, despite their prominence, these subtypes have not translated into therapeutic utility, and their biological basis remains unresolved. Here, we show that HGSC transcriptomic subtypes are largely determined by tumor cellular composition rather than intrinsic malignant transcriptional programs. By integrating controlled single-cell-derived pseudobulk simulations with deconvolution-based analysis of 1,834 primary HGSC tumors across RNA-seq and microarray cohorts, we demonstrate that subtype probabilities align along a composition-driven axis of stromal and immune variation. Cellular composition alone predicted subtype labels with high accuracy (ROC-AUC = 0.81-0.95) and explained a substantial fraction of subtype-associated transcriptomic variation, with the mesenchymal (C1.MES) subtype representing the most robust and reproducible example of composition-driven signal. Although a secondary, composition-independent expression signal is detectable, it does not define the dominant structure of subtype classification. These findings redefine HGSC transcriptomic subtypes as features of the tumor ecosystem rather than discrete malignant states. This reinterpretation has immediate implications for studies that use subtype labels to infer tumor-intrinsic biology and provides a generalizable framework for separating composition-driven and intrinsic signals in bulk tumor data. Significance StatementHGSC transcriptomic subtypes lack consistent clinical utility and remain biologically ambiguous. We show subtype assignments are largely driven by tumor cellular composition, and less so by distinct intrinsic tumor states.

cancer biology↗

Deconvolved tumor adipocyte proportions and high grade serous ovarian carcinoma survival

BackgroundSingle-cell-based analyses of high-grade serous ovarian carcinoma (HGSOC) survival have largely ignored adipocytes, which are fragile and under-represented in single-cell references. Adipocytes are known active components of the tumor microenvironment in many cancers, and HGSOC tumors frequently metastasize to the omentum, a lining of adipose tissue. MethodsWe created a composite reference that combines single-nucleus adipose profiles with published HGSOC single-cell data to deconvolve 588 bulk RNA-seq tumours from the Schildkraut cohorts. We used stage-stratified Cox models to quantify the association between intratumoural adipocyte fractions and overall survival while adjusting for age, body mass index (BMI), race, and residual disease. We also evaluated associations with deconvolved immune, stromal, and epithelial cell groups. ResultsA 10% increase in estimated tumor adipocyte content was associated with a 41% increase in the hazard of death (HR = 1.41, 95% CI 1.18-1.70, p = 0.0002) after adjusting for age, BMI and race (n=566). A 10% increase in immune cell proportion was associated with favorable survival (HR = 0.82, 95% CI 0.69-0.97, p = 0.024). Stromal and epithelial macro-fractions were not associated with survival. Associations with adipocyte and immune cell type proportions were unchanged in models additionally controlling the other cell type proportions. Results were similar after additionally adjusting for residual disease after debulking surgery. ConclusionsAdipocytes may be a tumor-intrinsic factor associated with adverse outcomes in HGSOC. Quantifying adipocyte burden using bulk RNA-seq could enhance risk stratification and guide the development of adipocyte-targeted therapies.

genomics↗

Missing cell types in single-cell references impact deconvolution of bulk data but are detectable

Advancements in RNA-sequencing have dramatically expanded our ability to study gene expression profiles of biological samples in bulk tissue and single cells. Deconvolution of bulk data with single-cell references provides the ability to study relative cell-type proportions, but most methods assume a reference is present for every cell type in bulk data. This is not true in all circumstances--cell types can be missing in single-cell profiles for many reasons. In this study, we examine the impact of missing cell types on deconvolution methods. Our experimental designs are simulation-based, using paired single-cell and single-nucleus data, since single-nucleus RNA-sequencing is able to preserve the nucleus of cell types that would otherwise be missing in a single-cell counterpart. These datasets allow us to examine the missing-cell-type phenomenon in deconvolution with realistic proportions. We apply three deconvolution methods that vary from straightforward to state-of-the-art: non-negative least squares, BayesPrism, and CIBERSORTx. We find that the performance of deconvolution methods is influenced by both the number and the similarity of missing cell types, consistent with prior results. Additionally, we find that missing cell-type profiles can be recovered from residuals using a simple non-negative matrix factorization strategy. We expect our simulation strategies and results to provide a starting point for those developing new deconvolution methods and help improve their to better account for the presence of missing cell types. Building off of our findings on simulated data, we then analyzed data from high-grade serous ovarian cancer; a tumor that has regions of highly variable levels of adipocytes dependent on the region from which it is sampled. We observe results consistent with simulation, namely that expression patterns from cell types likely to be missing appear present in residuals. Our results suggests that deconvolution methods should consider the possibility of missing cell types and provide a starting point to address this. Our source code for data simulation and analysis is freely available at https://github.com/greenelab/pred_missing_celltypes.

bioinformatics↗

Molecular subtypes of high grade serous ovarian cancer across racial groups and gene expression platforms

IntroductionHigh-grade serous carcinoma (HGSC) gene expression subtypes are associated with differential survival. We characterized HGSC gene expression in Black individuals and considered whether gene expression differences by race may contribute to poorer HGSC survival among Black versus non-Hispanic White individuals. MethodsWe included newly generated RNA-Seq data from Black and White individuals, and array-based genotyping data from four existing studies of White and Japanese individuals. We assigned subtypes using K-means clustering. Cluster- and dataset-specific gene expression patterns were summarized by moderated t-scores. We compared cluster-specific gene expression patterns across datasets by calculating the correlation between the summarized vectors of moderated t-scores. Following mapping to The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA)-derived HGSC subtypes, we used Cox proportional hazards models to estimate subtype-specific survival by dataset. ResultsCluster-specific gene expression was similar across gene expression platforms. Comparing the Black study population to the White and Japanese study populations, the immunoreactive subtype was more common (39% versus 23%-28%) and the differentiated subtype less common (7% versus 22%-31%). Patterns of subtype-specific survival were similar between the Black and White populations with RNA-Seq data; compared to mesenchymal cases, the risk of death was similar for proliferative and differentiated cases and suggestively lower for immunoreactive cases (Black population HR=0.79 [0.55, 1.13], White population HR=0.86 [0.62, 1.19]). ConclusionsA single, platform-agnostic pipeline can be used to assign HGSC gene expression subtypes. While the observed prevalence of HGSC subtypes varied by race, subtype-specific survival was similar. Statement of SignificanceA single pipeline was used to subtype ovarian high-grade serous carcinoma (HGSC) with array-based or RNA-Seq gene expression data. Subtype distributions differed by race, but subtype-specific survival was similar across racial groups.

cancer biology↗

BuDDI: Bulk Deconvolution with Domain Invariance to predict cell-type-specific perturbations from bulk

While single-cell experiments provide deep cellular resolution within a single sample, some single-cell experiments are inherently more challenging than bulk experiments due to dissociation difficulties, cost, or limited tissue availability. This creates a situation where we have deep cellular profiles of one sample or condition, and bulk profiles across multiple samples and conditions. To bridge this gap, we propose BuDDI (BUlk Deconvolution with Domain Invariance). BuDDI utilizes domain adaptation techniques to effectively integrate available corpora of case-control bulk and reference scRNA-seq observations to infer cell-type-specific perturbation effects. BuDDI achieves this by learning independent latent spaces within a single variational autoencoder (VAE) encompassing at least four sources of variability: 1) cell type proportion, 2) perturbation effect, 3) structured experimental variability, and 4) remaining variability. Since each latent space is encouraged to be independent, we simulate perturbation responses by independently composing each latent space to simulate cell-type-specific perturbation responses. We evaluated BuDDIs performance on simulated and real data with experimental designs of increasing complexity. We first validated that BuDDI could learn domain invariant latent spaces on data with matched samples across each source of variability. Then we validated that BuDDI could accurately predict cell-type-specific perturbation response when no single-cell perturbed profiles were used during training; instead, only bulk samples had both perturbed and non-perturbed observations. Finally, we validated BuDDI on predicting sex-specific differences, an experimental design where it is not possible to have matched samples. In each experiment, BuDDI outperformed all other comparative methods and baselines. As more reference atlases are completed, BuDDI provides a path to combine these resources with bulk-profiled treatment or disease signatures to study perturbations, sex differences, or other factors at single-cell resolution.

bioinformatics↗

Deconvolution reveals compositional differences in high-grade serous ovarian cancer subtypes

Ovarian cancer is a deadly disease with few effective therapies. The most common form is high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSOC). Transcriptomic subtypes of HGSOC have shown promise in characterizing tumor heterogeneity and are associated with survival. Gene expression signatures for the subtypes suggest variation in stromal cell types in the tumor microenvironment (TME). Here, we characterize the TME composition of HGSOC on a population scale by performing deconvolution on bulk transcriptomic data. We use comprehensive cell type profiles from 164 HGSOC tumor samples from two independent reference datasets, in order to compare cell type proportions across and within bulk transcriptomic datasets, and assess their alignment to the subtypes proposed by The Cancer Genome Atlas. We also assess the relationship between tumor composition and clinical outcomes. Our results suggest that HGSOC transcriptomic subtypes are driven by TME composition, specifically fibroblast and immune cell content, and we propose a modified HGSOC subtype model informed by cell composition.

bioinformatics↗

Analysis of scientific journalism in Nature reveals gender and regional disparities in coverage

Science journalism is a critical way for the public to learn about and benefit from scientific findings. Such journalism shapes the publics view of the current state of science and legitimizes experts. Journalists can only cite and quote a limited number of sources, who they may discover in their research, including recommendations by other scientists. Biases in either process may influence who is identified and ultimately included as a source. To examine potential biases in science journalism, we analyzed 22,001 non-research articles published by Nature and compared these with Nature-published research articles with respect to predicted gender and name origin. We extracted cited authors names and those of quoted speakers. While citations and quotations within a piece do not reflect the entire information-gathering process, they can provide insight into the demographics of visible sources. We then predicted gender and name origin of the cited authors and speakers. We compared articles with a comparator set made up of first and last authors within primary research articles in Nature and a subset of Springer Nature articles in the same time period. In our analysis, we found a skew toward quoting men in Nature science journalism. However, quotation is trending toward equal representation at a faster rate than authorship rates in academic publishing. Gender disparity in Nature quotes was dependent on the article type. We found a significant over-representation of names with predicted Celtic/English origin and under-representation of names with a predicted East Asian origin in both in extracted quotes and journal citations but dampened in citations.

scientific communication and education↗

pmVAE: Learning Interpretable Single-Cell Representations with Pathway Modules

MotivationDeep learning techniques have yielded tremendous progress in the field of computational biology over the last decade, however many of these techniques are opaque to the user. To provide interpretable results, methods have incorporated biological priors directly into the learning task; one such biological prior is pathway structure. While pathways represent most biological processes in the cell, the high level of correlation and hierarchical structure make it complicated to determine an appropriate computational representation. ResultsHere, we present pathway module Variational Autoencoder (pmVAE). Our method encodes pathway information by restricting the structure of our VAE to mirror gene-pathway memberships. Its architecture is composed of a set of subnetworks, which we refer to as pathway modules. The subnetworks learn interpretable latent representations by factorizing the latent space according to pathway gene sets. We directly address correlation between pathways by balancing a module-specific local loss and a global reconstruction loss. Furthermore, since many pathways are by nature hierarchical and therefore the product of multiple downstream signals, we model each pathway as a multidimensional vector. Due to their factorization over pathways, the representations allow for easy and interpretable analysis of multiple downstream effects, such as cell type and biological stimulus, within the contexts of each pathway. We compare pmVAE against two other state-of-the-art methods on two single-cell RNA-seq case-control data sets, demonstrating that our pathway representations are both more discriminative and consistent in detecting pathways targeted by a perturbation. Availability and implementationhttps://github.com/ratschlab/pmvae

bioinformatics↗

SF3B1 promotes tumor malignancy through splicing-independent co-activation of HIF1α

Mutations in the splicing factor SF3B1 are frequently occurring in various cancers and drive tumor progression through the activation of cryptic splice sites in multiple genes. Recent studies also demonstrate a positive correlation between expression levels of wildtype SF3B1 and tumor malignancy, but underlying mechanisms remain elusive. Here, we report that SF3B1 acts as an activator of HIF signaling through a splicing-independent mechanism. We demonstrate that SF3B1 forms a heterotrimer with HIF1 and HIF1{beta}, facilitating binding of the HIF1 complex to hypoxia response elements (HREs) to activate target gene expression. We further validate the relevance of this mechanism for tumor progression. Monoallelic deletion of Sf3b1 impedes formation and progression of hypoxic pancreatic cancer via impaired HIF signaling, but is well tolerated in normoxic chromophobe renal cell carcinoma. Our work uncovers an essential role of SF3B1 in HIF1 signaling, providing a causal link between high SF3B1 expression and aggressiveness of solid tumors.

cell biology↗

Pan-cancer study of heterogeneous RNA aberrations

We present the most comprehensive catalogue of cancer-associated gene alterations through characterization of tumor transcriptomes from 1,188 donors of the Pan-Cancer Analysis of Whole Genomes project. Using matched whole-genome sequencing data, we attributed RNA alterations to germline and somatic DNA alterations, revealing likely genetic mechanisms. We identified 444 associations of gene expression with somatic non-coding single-nucleotide variants. We found 1,872 splicing alterations associated with somatic mutation in intronic regions, including novel exonization events associated with Alu elements. Somatic copy number alterations were the major driver of total gene and allele-specific expression (ASE) variation. Additionally, 82% of gene fusions had structural variant support, including 75 of a novel class called \"bridged\" fusions, in which a third genomic location bridged two different genes. Globally, we observe transcriptomic alteration signatures that differ between cancer types and have associations with DNA mutational signatures. Given this unique dataset of RNA alterations, we also identified 1,012 genes significantly altered through both DNA and RNA mechanisms. Our study represents an extensive catalog of RNA alterations and reveals new insights into the heterogeneous molecular mechanisms of cancer gene alterations.

genomics↗