Bro-Jorgensen, J. | Search bioRxiv

bioRxiv2026

Species diversity increases information flow about predation in bird communities

The Biodiversity-Ecosystem Functioning (BEF) literature has shown species diversity to be essential for ecosystem functioning and services. Yet although acquiring information through interspecific networks can impact ecosystem functioning, it is unclear how it is modulated by species diversity. Eliciting vocal responses using predator models across a latitudinal gradient, we first show that the species diversity of birds increases public information about predation both in the low-cost system of mobbing and in the higher-cost system of alarm calls. A similar result was also found across a fragment area gradient for mobbing; this system was then used to test how species diversity affects interspecific information flow in mobbing communities. We set up two BEF playback experiments, manipulating the species richness level of the playback sound files by varying the number of species producing mobbing calls (one, two, four, eight species). In an experiment in which the call rate across treatments was held constant, and only heterospecific responses were counted, increasing species richness of the sound files increased the number of species and individuals responding, the number of calls produced and their frequency range, and decreased latency to call. An experiment in which call rate increased with the addition of species in each treatment showed a similar, but stronger pattern. There was little evidence that the signals of one particular species changed responses. This supports the hypothesis that the species diversity of a community is a key component influencing the quantity and quality of information flow inside it.

ecology↗

bioRxiv2024

Analysis of sparse animal social networks

Low-density social networks can be common in animal societies, even among species generally considered to be highly social. Social network analysis is commonly used to analyse animal societal structure, but edge weight (strength of association between two individuals) estimation methods designed for dense networks can produce biased measures when applied to low-density networks. Frequentist methods suffer when data availability is low, because they contain an inherent flat prior that will accept any possible edge weight value, and contain no uncertainty in their output. Bayesian methods can accept alternative priors, so can provide more reliable edge weights that include a measure of uncertainty, but they can only reduce bias when sensible prior values are selected. Currently, neither accounts for zero-inflation, so they produce edge weight estimates biased towards stronger associations than the true social network, which can be seen through diagnostic plots of data quality against output estimate. We address this by adding zero-inflation to the model, and demonstrate the process using group-based data from a population of male African savannah elephants. We show that the Bayesian approach performs better than the frequentist to reduce the bias caused by these problems, though the Bayesian requires careful consideration of the priors. We recommend the use of a Bayesian framework, but with a conditional prior that allows the modelling of zero-inflation. This reflects the fact that edge weight derivation is a two-step process: i) probability of ever interacting, and ii) frequency of interaction for those who do. Additional conditional priors could be added where the biology requires it, for example in a society with strong community structure, such as female elephants in which kin structure would create additional levels of social clustering. Although this approach was inspired by reducing bias observed in sparse networks, it could have value for networks of all densities.

animal behavior and cognition↗