Search bioRxiv⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Brenninger, F. A.

Publications and source records attributed to Brenninger, F. A..

2 recordsLinked to original sources

Infection dynamics of endosymbionts that manipulate arthropod reproduction

A large proportion of arthropod species are infected with endosymbionts, some of which selfishly alter host reproduction. The currently known forms of parasitic reproductive manipulations are male-killing, feminization, cytoplasmic incompatibility, parthenogenesis induction and distortion of sex allocation. While all of these phenomena represent adaptations that enhance parasite spread, they differ in the mechanisms involved and the consequent infection dynamics. We focus here on the latter aspect, summarizing existing theoretical literature on infection dynamics of all known reproductive manipulation types, and completing the remaining knowledge gaps where dynamics have not been modelled yet. Our unified framework includes the minimal model components required to describe the effects of each manipulation. We establish invasion criteria for all potential combinations of manipulative endosymbionts, yielding predictions for an endosymbionts increase from rarity within a host population that is initially either uninfected or infected with a different symbiont strain. We consider diplodiploid and haplodiploid hosts, as the mechanisms as well as the infection dynamics of reproductive manipulations can differ between them. Our framework reveals that endosymbionts that a priori have the best invasion prospects are not necessarily the most commonly found ones in nature; priority effects play a role too, and cytoplasmic incompatibility excels in this regard. As a whole, considerations of the ease with which a symbiont spreads have to be complemented with knowledge of how easy it is to achieve a particular manipulation, and other factors influencing host switches.

evolutionary biology↗

Sex-specific immunocompetence: resistance and tolerance can both be futile but not under the same circumstances

Immunocompetence evolution can involve a resistance is futile scenario, if parasite encounter rates are so high that high investment in resistance only marginally delays infection. Here, we investigate two understudied aspects of futility. First, immunocompetence is usefully categorized as reducing the rate of becoming infected (resistance) or reducing the negative fitness consequences of infection once it happened (tolerance). We compare the prospects of futility for resistance, tolerance, and their joint occurrence, showing that resistance futility arises with respect to parasite encounter rates, while tolerance futility arises with respect to parasite virulence. However, if the same host trait improves pleiotropically both resistance and tolerance, futility disappears altogether and immunity investment remains profitable when increasing parasite encounter rates, virulence, or both. Second, we examine how sexual selection strength impacts these findings. If one sex (typically males) is near the faster end of a fast-slow continuum of life histories, then life history patterns reflecting futility can evolve sex-specificity. The solutions often feature sexual dimorphism in immunocompetence, but not always in the direction of strong sexual selection yielding low immunity: sexual selection can select for faster and sicker lives, but if sexual selection also causes traits that impact parasite encounter rates, the results are strongly dependent on whether futility (along any axis) plays a role. Lay SummaryIntuition suggests that investment into immunity is higher, when hosts frequently encounter parasites. While there are examples that confirm this, in other cases, hosts have been shown to abandon immune defenses under high parasite pressure. We reconcile these findings by modelling the optimal host resource allocation towards immunity under varying parasite pressure and strength of sexual selection. Our results show two axes along which immunity investments are futile and should therefore be abandoned in favor of investing into reproduction: resisting infection becomes futile under high parasite abundance, while tolerating the harmful effects of infection is not beneficial under ever increasing parasitic virulence. However, investments of organisms that are capable of both resistance and tolerance mechanisms yield fitness payoffs also when parasites are highly virulent and abundant. This work highlights the impact of parasites and immune defenses on optimal immunity investment levels in hosts, an insight which also complements theory on sex-specific immunity.

evolutionary biology↗