Biology subjects

Bentley, S. D.

Publications and source records attributed to Bentley, S. D..

At least 37 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

bioRxiv2023

PAN-GWES: Pangenome-spanning epistasis and co-selection analysis via de Bruijn graphs

Studies of bacterial adaptation and evolution are hampered by the difficulty of measuring traits such as virulence, drug resistance and transmissibility in large populations. In contrast, it is now feasible to obtain high-quality complete assemblies of many bacterial genomes thanks to scalable and affordable long-read sequencing technology. To exploit this opportunity we introduce a phenotype- and alignment-free method for discovering co-selected and epistatically interacting genomic variation from genome assemblies covering both core and accessory parts of genomes. Our approach uses a compact coloured de Bruijn graph to approximate the intra-genome distances between pairs of loci for a collection of bacterial genomes to account for the impacts of linkage disequilibrium (LD). We demonstrate the versatility of our approach to efficiently identify associations between loci linked with drug resistance and adaptation to the hospital niche in the major human bacterial pathogens Streptococcus pneumoniae and Enterococcus faecalis.

bioinformatics↗

bioRxiv2023

Evidence of virulence and antimicrobial resistance in Streptococcus pneumoniae serotype 16F lineages

IntroductionDue to the emergence of non-vaccine serotypes in vaccinated populations, Streptococcus pneumoniae remains a major global health challenge despite advances in vaccine development. Serotype 16F is among the predominant non-vaccine serotypes identified among vaccinated infants in South Africa (SA). AimTo characterise lineages and antimicrobial resistance in 16F isolates obtained from South Africa and placed the local findings in a global context. MethodologyWe analysed 10923 S. pneumoniae carriage isolates obtained from infants recruited as part of a broader SA birth cohort. We inferred serotype, resistance profile for penicillin, chloramphenicol, cotrimoxazole, erythromycin and tetracycline, and Global Pneumococcal Sequence Clusters (GPSCs) from genomic data. To ensure global representation, we also included S. pneumoniae carriage and disease isolates from the Global Pneumococcal Sequencing (GPS) project database (n=19,607, collected from 49 countries across five continents, years covered (1995 - 2018), accessed on 17th March 2022). ResultsNine percent (934/10923) of isolates obtained from infants in the Drakenstein community in SA and 2% (419/19607) of genomes in the GPS dataset were serotype 16F. Serotype 16F isolates were from 28 different lineages of S. pneumoniae, with GPSC33 and GPSC46 having the highest proportion of serotype 16F isolates at 26% (346/1353) and 53% (716/1353), respectively. Serotype 16F isolates were identified globally, however, most isolates were collected from Africa. GPSC33 was associated with carriage [OR (95% CI) 0.24 (0.09 - 0.66); p=0.003], while GPSC46 was associated with disease [OR (95% CI) 19.9 (2.56 - 906.50); p=0.0004]. 10% (37/346) and 15% (53/346) of isolates within GPSC33 had genes associated with resistance to penicillin and co-trimoxazole, respectively, and 18% (128/716) of isolates within GPSC46 had genes associated with resistance to co-trimoxazole. Resistant isolates formed genetic clusters which may suggest emerging resistant lineages. DiscussionSerotype 16F lineages are common in Southern Africa. Some of these lineages are associated with disease, and resistance to penicillin and cotrimoxazole. We recommend continuous genomic surveillance to determine long term impact of serotype 16F lineages on vaccine efficacy and antimicrobial therapy globally. Investing in vaccine strategies that offer protection over a wide range of serotypes/lineages remains essential. DATA SUMMARYThe sequencing reads for the genomes analysed have been deposited in the European Nucleotide Archive and the accession numbers for each isolate are listed in Supplementary Table1. Phylogenetic tree of serotype 16F pneumococcal genomes and associated metadata are available for download and visualisation on the Microreact website: Phylogenies of seotype 16F, GPSC33 and GPSC46 are available on the Microreact serotype-16F, GPSC33 and GPSC46, respectively. IMPACT STATEMENTThis study shows that serotype 16F lineages are predominant in Southern Africa and are associated with disease and antimicrobial resistance. Although serotype 16F has been included in the newer formulation of the upcoming vaccine formulations of PCV21 and IVT-25, continuous surveillance to determine long term impact of serotype 16F lineages on vaccines and antimicrobial therapy remains essential.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2023

Three Accessory Gene Clusters Drive Host-Adaptation in Group B Streptococcus

Streptococcus agalactiae (Group B Streptococcus, GBS) is a major pathogen of humans and animals, posing a threat to human health as well as food security. Here, we investigate the role of genomic mechanisms, including homologous recombination and horizontal gene transfer, in shaping the population structure of GBS and its adaptation to three major host groups (humans, cattle, fishes). We demonstrate that the GBS population comprises host-specialist, host-adapted lineages as well as host generalists, and that these categories differ in their level or recombination. Although the accessory genome at large varies by lineage rather than host, genome wide association studies show that host association is driven by three accessory genome clusters, regardless of lineage or breadth of the host spectrum. These genomic clusters (scpB in human GBS, lactose operon in bovine GBS, Locus 3 in fish GBS) are known (scpB, Lac.2) or shown here (Locus 3) to be functionally relevant and are shared with other streptococcal species occupying the same host niche. These findings demonstrate the importance of considering the role of non-human host species in the evolution of GBS, including high risk clones that may lead to interspecies transmission and affect efficacy of future GBS vaccines.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2023

Inter-species gene flow drives ongoing evolution of Streptococcus pyogenes and Streptococcus dysgalactiae subsp. equisimilis

Streptococcus dysgalactiae subsp. equisimilis (SDSE) is an emerging cause of human infection with invasive disease incidence and clinical manifestations comparable to the closely related species, Streptococcus pyogenes. Through systematic genomic analyses of 501 disseminated SDSE strains, we demonstrate extensive overlap between the genomes of SDSE and S. pyogenes. More than 75% of core genes are shared between the two species with one third demonstrating evidence of cross-species recombination. Twenty-five percent of mobile genetic element (MGE) clusters and 16 of 55 SDSE MGE insertion regions were found across species. Assessing potential cross-protection from leading S. pyogenes vaccine candidates on SDSE, 12/34 preclinical vaccine antigen genes were shown to be present in >99% of isolates of both species. Relevant to possible vaccine evasion, six vaccine candidate genes demonstrated evidence of inter-species recombination. These findings demonstrate previously unappreciated levels of genomic overlap between these closely related pathogens with implications for streptococcal pathobiology, disease surveillance and prevention.

microbiology↗

bioRxiv2023

The emergence and diversification of a zoonotic pathogen from within the microbiota of intensively farmed pigs

The expansion and intensification of livestock production is predicted to promote the emergence of pathogens. As pathogens sometimes jump between species this can affect the health of humans as well as livestock. Here we investigate how livestock microbiota can act as a source of these emerging pathogens through analysis of Streptococcus suis, a ubiquitous component of the respiratory microbiota of pigs that is also a major cause of disease on pig farms and an important zoonotic pathogen. Combining molecular dating, phylogeography and comparative genomic analyses of a large collection of isolates, we find that several pathogenic lineages of S. suis emerged in the 19th and 20th centuries, during an early period of growth in pig farming. These lineages have since spread between countries and continents, mirroring trade in live pigs. They are distinguished by the presence of three genomic islands with putative roles in metabolism and cell adhesion, and an ongoing reduction in genome size, which may reflect their recent shift to a more pathogenic ecology. Reconstructions of the evolutionary histories of these islands reveal constraints on pathogen emergence that could inform control strategies, with pathogenic lineages consistently emerging from one subpopulation of S. suis and acquiring genes through horizontal transfer from other pathogenic lineages. These results shed light on the capacity of the microbiota to rapidly evolve to exploit changes in their host population and suggest that the impact of changes in farming on the pathogenicity and zoonotic potential of S. suis is yet to be fully realised.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2023

Geographic migration and vaccine-induced fitness changes of Streptococcus pneumoniae

Streptococcus pneumoniae is a leading cause of pneumonia and meningitis worldwide. Many different serotypes co-circulate endemically in any one location. The extent and mechanisms of spread, and vaccine-driven changes in fitness and antimicrobial resistance (AMR), remain largely unquantified. Using geolocated genome sequences from South Africa (N=6910, 2000-2014) we developed models to reconstruct spread, pairing detailed human mobility data and genomic data. Separately we estimated the population level changes in fitness of strains that are (vaccine type, VT) and are not (non-vaccine type, NVT) included in the vaccine, first implemented in 2009, as well as differences in strain fitness between those that are and are not resistant to penicillin. We estimated that pneumococci only become homogenously mixed across South Africa after about 50 years of transmission, with the slow spread driven by the focal nature of human mobility. Further, in the years following vaccine implementation the relative fitness of NVT compared to VT strains increased (RR: 1.29 [95% CI 1.20-1.37]) - with an increasing proportion of these NVT strains becoming penicillin resistant. Our findings point to highly entrenched, slow transmission and indicate that initial vaccine-linked decreases in AMR may be transient. One-Sentence SummaryWe describe geographic migration, and fitness dynamics conferred by NVT strains and AMR, for the globally endemic pathogen Streptococcus pneumoniae.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2022

Nasopharyngeal competition dynamics are likely to be altered following vaccine introduction: bacteriocin prevalence and diversity among Icelandic and Kenyan pneumococci

Bacteriocins are antimicrobial peptides produced by bacteria to inhibit other bacteria in the surrounding environment. Streptococcus pneumoniae is a leading cause of disease worldwide and colonises the healthy human nasopharynx, where it competes for space and nutrients. Pneumococcal conjugate vaccines have reduced the incidence of disease, but they also restructure the bacterial population, and this restructuring likely alters the nasopharyngeal competition dynamics. Here, the distribution of bacteriocins was examined in over 5000 carriage and disease-causing pneumococci from Iceland and Kenya, recovered before and after the introduction of pneumococcal vaccination. Overall, up to eleven different bacteriocin gene clusters were identified per pneumococcus. Significant differences in the prevalence of bacteriocins were observed before and after vaccine introduction, and among carriage and disease-causing pneumococci, which were largely explained by the bacterial population structure. Genetically similar pneumococci generally harboured the same bacteriocins although sometimes different repertoires of bacteriocins were observed, which suggested that horizontal transfer of bacteriocin clusters had occurred. These findings demonstrated that vaccine-mediated changes in the pneumococcal population altered the prevalence and distribution of bacteriocins. The consequences of this for pneumococcal colonisation and disease remain to be determined.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2022

The population-level impact of Enterococcus faecalis genetics on intestinal colonisation and extraintestinal infection

Enterococcus faecalis is a commensal pathogenic bacterium commonly found in the human gastrointestinal tract and a cause of opportunistic infections typically associated with multidrug resistance. The E. faecalis genetic changes associated with pathogenicity and extraintestinal infection, particularly through gut-to-bloodstream translocation, are poorly understood. Here, we investigate the E. faecalis genetic signatures associated with intestinal colonisation and extraintestinal infection and infection of hospitalised and non-hospitalised individuals using heritability estimation and a genome-wide association study (GWAS). We analysed 750 whole-genome sequences of faecal and bloodstream E. faecalis isolates from hospitalised patients and non-hospitalised individuals, respectively, predominantly in Europe. We found that E. faecalis infection of individuals depending on their hospitalisation status and extraintestinal infection are heritable traits and that [~]24% and [~]34% of their variation is explained by the considered genetic effects, respectively. Further, a GWAS using linear mixed models did not pinpoint any clear enrichment of individual genetic changes in isolates from different isolation sites and individuals with varying hospitalisation statuses, suggesting that these traits are highly polygenic. Altogether, our findings indicate that E. faecalis infection and extraintestinal infection are influenced by variation in genetic, host, and environmental factors, and ultimately the opportunistic pathogenic lifestyle of this versatile host generalist bacterium.

microbiology↗

bioRxiv2022

Post-vaccine epidemiology of serotype 3 pneumococci identifies transformation inhibition through prophage-driven alteration of a non-coding RNA

The respiratory pathogen Streptococcus pneumoniae (the pneumococcus) is a genetically diverse bacterium associated with over 100 immunologically-distinct polysaccharide capsules (serotypes). Polysaccharide conjugate vaccines (PCVs) have successfully eliminated multiple targeted serotypes, yet the mucoid serotype 3 has persisted despite its inclusion in PCV13. This capsule type is predominantly associated with a single globally-disseminated strain, GPSC12 (CC180), which was split into clades by a genomic analysis. Clade I, the most common, rarely underwent transformation, but was typically infected with the prophage {phi}OXC141. Prior to the introduction of PCV13, this clades composition shifted towards a {phi}OXC141-negative subpopulation in a systematically-sampled UK collection. In the post-PCV era, more rapidly-recombining non-Clade I isolates, also {phi}OXC141-negative, have risen in prevalence. The low in vitro transformation efficiency of a Clade I isolate could not be fully explained by the [~]100-fold reduction attributable to the serotype 3 capsule. Accordingly, prophage {phi}OXC141 was found to modify csRNA3, a non-coding RNA that inhibits the induction of transformation. This alteration was identified in [~]30% of all pneumococci, and was particularly common in the unusually-clonal serotype 1 GPSC2 strain. RNA-seq and quantitative reverse transcriptase PCR data demonstrated the altered csRNA3 was more effective at inhibiting production of the competence stimulating peptide pheromone. This interference with the quorum sensing needed to induce competence lowered the rate of spontaneous transformation, reducing the risk of the prophage being deleted by homologous recombination. Hence the selfish prophage-driven alteration of a regulatory RNA limits cell-cell communication and horizontal gene transfer, complicating the interpretation of post-vaccine population dynamics.

microbiology↗

bioRxiv2022

Robust analysis of prokaryotic pangenome gene gain and loss rates with Panstripe

Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) plays a critical role in the evolution and diversification of many microbial species. The resulting dynamics of gene gain and loss can have important implications for the development of antibiotic resistance and the design of vaccine and drug interventions. Methods for the analysis of gene presence/absence patterns typically do not account for errors introduced in the automated annotation and clustering of gene sequences. In particular, methods adapted from ecological studies, including the pangenome gene accumulation curve, can be misleading as they may reflect the underlying diversity in the temporal sampling of genomes rather than a difference in the dynamics of HGT. Here, we introduce Panstripe, a method based on Generalised Linear Regression that is robust to population structure, sampling bias and errors in the predicted presence/absence of genes. We demonstrate using simulations that Panstripe can effectively identify differences in the rate and number of genes involved in HGT events, and illustrate its capability by analysing several diverse bacterial genome datasets representing major human pathogens. Panstripe is freely available as an R package at https://github.com/gtonkinhill/panstripe.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2022

Moonlighting proteins activate transformation in multidrug-resistant Streptococcus pneumoniae epigenetic phase variants

Despite enabling Streptococcus pneumoniae to acquire antibiotic resistance and evade vaccine-induced immunity, transformation occurs at variable rates across pneumococci. Phase variants of isolate RMV7, distinguished by altered methylation patterns driven by the translocating variable restriction-modification (tvr) locus, differed significantly in their transformation efficiencies and biofilm thicknesses. These differences were replicated when the corresponding tvr alleles were introduced into an RMV7 derivative lacking the locus. RNA-seq identified differential expression of the type 1 pilus, causing the variation in biofilm formation, and inhibition of competence induction in the less transformable variant, RMV7domi. This was partly attributable to lower expression of ManLMN in RMV7domi, which promoted competence induction through importing N-acetylglucosamine. This effect was potentiated by orthologues of the gram-negative competence regulatory machinery. Furthermore, a phage-related chromosomal island was more active in RMV7domi, which inhibited transformation by increasing expression of the stress response proteins ClpP and HrcA. However, HrcA increased competence induction in the other variant, with its effects depending on Ca2+ supplementation or heat shock. Hence the heterogeneity in transformation efficiency likely reflects the diverse signalling pathways by which it is affected. This regulatory complexity will modulate population-wide responses to synchronising quorum sensing signals to produce co-ordinated yet stochastic "bet hedging" behaviour.

microbiology↗

bioRxiv2022

Pneumococcal within-host diversity during colonisation, transmission and treatment

Characterising the genetic diversity of pathogens within the host promises to greatly improve surveillance and reconstruction of transmission chains. For bacteria, it also informs our understanding of inter-strain competition, and how this shapes the distribution of resistant and sensitive bacteria. Here we study the genetic diversity of Streptococcus pneumoniae within individual infants and their mothers by deep sequencing whole pneumococcal populations from longitudinal nasopharyngeal samples. We demonstrate deep sequencing has unsurpassed sensitivity for detecting multiple colonisation, doubling the rate at which highly invasive serotype 1 bacteria were detected in carriage compared to gold-standard methods. The greater resolution identified an elevated rate of transmission from mothers to their children in the first year of the childs life. Comprehensive treatment data demonstrated infants were at an elevated risk of both the acquisition, and persistent colonisation, of a multidrug resistant bacterium following antimicrobial treatment. Some alleles were enriched after antimicrobial treatment, suggesting they aided persistence, but generally purifying selection dominated within-host evolution. Rates of co-colonisation imply that in the absence of treatment, susceptible lineages outcompeted resistant lineages within the host. These results demonstrate the many benefits of deep sequencing for the genomic surveillance of bacterial pathogens.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2021

Pneumococcal genetic variability influences age-dependent bacterial carriage

The pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV) primarily reduces disease burden in adults through a reduction in carriage prevalence of invasive serotypes in children. Current vaccine formulations are the same for both adults and children, but tailoring these formulations to age category could optimize vaccine efficacy. Identification of specific pneumococcal genetic factors associated with carriage in younger or older age groups may suggest alternative formulations and contribute to a better mechanistic understanding of immunity. Here, we used whole genome sequencing to dissect pneumococcal variation associated with age. We performed genome sequencing in a large carriage cohort, and conducted a meta-analysis with an existing carriage study. We compiled a dictionary of pathogen genetic variation including serotype, sequence cluster, sequence elements, SNPs, burden combined rare variants, and clusters of orthologous genes (COGs) for each cohort - all of which used in a genome-wide association with host age. Age-dependent colonization had some heritability, though this varied between cohorts (h2 = 0.10, 0.00 - 0.69 95% CI in the first; h2 = 0.46, 0.33 - 0.60 95% CI in the second cohort). We found that serotypes and genetic background (strain) explained most of the heritability in each cohort (h2serotype = 0.06 and h2GPSC = 0.04 in the first; h2 serotype = 0.20 and h2 GPSC = 0.23 in the second cohort). We found one candidate association (p = 1.2x10-9) upstream of an accessory Sec-dependent serine-rich glycoprotein adhesin. Overall, association with age was highly cohort and strain dependent, supporting proposals for a future vaccination strategy which is primarily targeted using serotypes rather than proteins, and is tailored towards specific pathogen populations.

microbiology↗

bioRxiv2021

The role of interspecies recombinations in the evolution of antibiotic resistant pneumococci

AbstractThe evolutionary histories of the antibiotic-resistant Streptococcus pneumoniae lineages PMEN3 and PMEN9 were reconstructed using global collections of genomes. In PMEN3, one resistant clade spread worldwide, and underwent 25 serotype switches, enabling evasion of vaccine-induced immunity. In PMEN9, only 9 switches were detected, and multiple resistant lineages emerged independently and circulated locally. In Germany, PMEN9s expansion correlated significantly with the macrolide:penicillin consumption ratio. These isolates were penicillin sensitive but macrolide resistant, through a homologous recombination that integrated Tn1207.1 into a competence gene, preventing further diversification via transformation. Analysis of a species-wide dataset found 183 acquisitions of macrolide resistance, and multiple gains of the tetracycline-resistant transposon Tn916, through homologous recombination, often originating in other streptococcal species. Consequently, antibiotic selection preserves atypical recom- bination events that cause sequence divergence and structural variation throughout the S. pneumoniae chromosome. These events reveal the genetic exchanges between species normally counter-selected until perturbed by clinical interventions.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2020

Patterns of within-host genetic diversity in SARS-CoV-2

Monitoring the spread of SARS-CoV-2 and reconstructing transmission chains has become a major public health focus for many governments around the world. The modest mutation rate and rapid transmission of SARS-CoV-2 prevents the reconstruction of transmission chains from consensus genome sequences, but within-host genetic diversity could theoretically help identify close contacts. Here we describe the patterns of within-host diversity in 1,181 SARS-CoV-2 samples sequenced to high depth in duplicate. 95% of samples show within-host mutations at detectable allele frequencies. Analyses of the mutational spectra revealed strong strand asymmetries suggestive of damage or RNA editing of the plus strand, rather than replication errors, dominating the accumulation of mutations during the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic. Within and between host diversity show strong purifying selection, particularly against nonsense mutations. Recurrent within-host mutations, many of which coincide with known phylogenetic homoplasies, display a spectrum and patterns of purifying selection more suggestive of mutational hotspots than recombination or convergent evolution. While allele frequencies suggest that most samples result from infection by a single lineage, we identify multiple putative examples of co-infection. Integrating these results into an epidemiological inference framework, we find that while sharing of within-host variants between samples could help the reconstruction of transmission chains, mutational hotspots and rare cases of superinfection can confound these analyses.

genomics↗

bioRxiv2020

Identification of colonisation and virulence determinants of Streptococcus pneumoniae via experimental evolution in mouse infection models

Streptococcus pneumoniae is a commensal of the human nasopharynx and a major cause of respiratory and invasive disease. Pneumococcus stimulates upper respiratory tract inflammation that promotes shedding from mucosal surfaces and transmission to new hosts. Colonisation and transmission are partially antagonistic processes. Adhesion to surfaces and evasion of host responses favours the former, whilst detachment, promoted by inflammation, is necessary for the latter. We sought to determine how adaptation and evolution of pneumococcus within its nasopharyngeal niche might progress when selective pressures associated with transmission were removed. This was achieved by serial passage of pneumococci in mouse models of nasopharyngeal carriage, manually transferring bacteria between mice. To assess the role of host environmental factors on pneumococcal evolution, we also performed analogous experimental evolution in a mouse pneumonia model, passaging pneumococci through lungs. Nasopharynx-passaged pneumococci became more effective colonisers, whilst those evolved within lungs showed reduced virulence. We observed selection of mutations in genes associated with cell wall biogenesis and metabolism in both nasopharynx and lung lineages, but identified prominent examples of parallel evolution that were niche specific. We focussed on gpsA, a gene in which the same single nucleotide polymorphism arose in two independently evolved nasopharynx-passaged lineages. We identified a single nucleotide change conferring resistance to oxidative stress and enhanced nasopharyngeal colonisation potential. We show that gpsA is also a frequent target of mutation during human colonisation. These findings highlight the role played by the host environment in determining trajectories of bacterial evolution and the potential of experimental evolution in animal infection models for identification of novel pathogen virulence and colonisation factors.

microbiology↗

bioRxiv2020

The effect of recombination on the evolution of a population of Neisseria meningitidis

Neisseria meningitidis (the meningococcus) is a major human pathogen with a history of high invasive disease burden, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa. Our current understanding of the evolution of meningococcal genomes is limited by the rarity of large-scale genomic population studies and lack of in-depth investigation of the genomic events associated with routine pathogen transmission. Here we fill this knowledge gap by a detailed analysis of 2,839 meningococcal genomes obtained through a carriage study of over 50,000 samples collected systematically in Burkina Faso, West Africa, before, during, and after the serogroup A vaccine rollout, 2009-2012. Our findings indicate that the meningococcal genome is highly dynamic, with recombination hotspots and frequent gene sharing across deeply separated lineages in a structured population. Furthermore, our findings illustrate the profound effect of population structure on genome flexibility, with some lineages in Burkina Faso being orders of magnitude more recombinant than others. We also examine the effect of selection on the population, in particular how it is correlated with recombination. We find that recombination principally acts to prevent the accumulation of deleterious mutations, although we do also find an example of recombination acting to speed the adaptation of a gene. In general, we show the importance of recombination in the evolution of a geographically expansive population with deep population structure in a short timescale. This has important consequences for our ability to both foresee the outcomes of vaccination programmes and, using surveillance data, predict when lineages of the meningococcus are likely to become a public health concern.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2020

Producing Polished Prokaryotic Pangenomes with the Panaroo Pipeline

Population-level comparisons of prokaryotic genomes must take into account the substantial differences in gene content, resulting from frequent horizontal gene transfer, gene duplication and gene loss. However, the automated annotation of prokaryotic genomes is imperfect, and errors due to fragmented assemblies, contamination, diverse gene families and mis-assemblies accumulate over the population, leading to profound consequences when analysing the set of all genes found in a species. Here we introduce Panaroo, a graph based pangenome clustering tool that is able to account for many of the sources of error introduced during the annotation of prokaryotic genome assemblies. We verified our approach through extensive simulations of de novo assemblies using the infinitely many genes model and by analysing a number of publicly available large bacterial genome datasets. Using a highly clonal Mycobacterium tuberculosis dataset as a negative control case, we show that failing to account for annotation errors can lead to pangenome estimates that are dominated by error. We additionally demonstrate the utility of the improved graphical output provided by Panaroo by performing a pan-genome wide association study in Neisseria gonorrhoeae and by analysing gene gain and loss rates across 51 of the major global pneumococcal sequence clusters. Panaroo is freely available under an open source MIT licence at https://github.com/gtonkinhill/panaroo.

genomics↗